I find those reticles with a horseshoe or ring around them to be distracting, and yes I know what their purpose is. Give me a crosshair/duplex/T-plex, preferably with a lighted dot in the middle.
OTOH, some of the Sightron stuff looks pretty good, so I’ve added them to the list of possibles.
The reticle on my Bushnell AR 1-6 has almost a complete circle on it with a dot sitting on a post. I didn't think I would like it, but I ended up loving after I used it.
I have optics on a couple of my AR's. One is outside the parameters of this discussion, but one is a Burris 1-6 LPVO with an illuminated reticle. I haven't really used it enough to give a comprehensive evaluation, only to say it's okay optically and I had no trouble dialing it adequately to hunt with it this fall...killed one deer with it. I'm looking forward to using it some more when I get the opportunity for some range time.
This thread motivated me to dig out the above mentioned rifle and scope (been put away since fall) and get somewhat reacquainted with it. It's an RT-6 and the lighted part of the reticle is a circle/dot. Brightness is adjustable via dial on the side and between each increment of brightness is an "Off" position. Interesting (to me anyway) was the fact that with magnification set at 1, it actually seems like a little less than 1, in other words, a slight wide-angle effect.
I would add that if the primary purpose of this rifle is defense, then you want a true 1X on the low end for close up situations. In most cases you don't need a lot of magnification for SD, but you do need something that is fast at 5 yards.
If "home defense" is truly your #1 goal, then probably NO OPTICAL sight may be best. Make your rear peep sight opening as large a ghost ring as you can. Paint your front sight bright orange or green. Your encounters are likely to be be very close, and you may be more likely to be "pointing" rather than "aiming". You'll be able to be more aware of your surroundings, and the perp's movement with iron sights, and not lose precise time trying to: find the perp in your scope, and not be so focused on on thing ("aiming"). There may be more than one perp, and a large ghost ring rear will allow enough "aiming", but you will also be able to maintain observation/assessment of the "perp area" for his/her team members.
If optics absolutely necessary, then employ the KISS method: Weaver micro-trac steel-tubed k1.5
Or, something like a Weaver Classic (Japan) 1-3x.
I vote for a big honking ghost ring rear peep sight...and practicing with it from 5 - 50 feet.
One more thing I think is very desirable on a defense rifle is daylight bright illumination. A lot of less expensive scopes have illumination, but it's not daylight bright. When you're shooting under pressure, illumination really helps, no matter what the light conditions are.
Bought a Sig Tango 1-6X24 from Doug like the looks and reticle capped .5 inch adjustments 44 " travel. Free Ground shipping a good deal for Alaskans as most ship Air ordered it on Monday here by Thursday! thanks Doug
kk alaska
Alaska 7 months of winter then 5 months of tourists
Bought a Sig Tango 1-6X24 from Doug like the looks and reticle capped .5 inch adjustments 44 " travel. Free Ground shipping a good deal for Alaskans as most ship Air ordered it on Monday here by Thursday! thanks Doug
Finally went with the Steiner 1-4x 30mm with the diamond and dot illuminated reticle. Seems like it is going to fit the bill.
"I know you believe that you understand what you think that I said... But I'm not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant." ( A quote of my Father)
Give me a crosshair/duplex/T-plex, preferably with a lighted dot in the middle.
👍 I’d say a heavy duplex on a 1-6 would be the Bee’s Knees. If your combat rifle in waiting is a 5.56 16 to 20” barrel carbine, does a FFP mil reticle with kill zone outline really do anything clinically significant for you? Forgive my ignorance but it seems to me such an outfit would be prepped for fast acquisition of target at close to mid range out to 150ish yards. A heavy duplex or triplex does that without batteries or quantum calculus. At say 300 yds max a more unhurried shot should be absolutely doable on a human torso target. Some feel a lighted reference point is a good thing but a heavy reticle can make that not only redundant but unrequired. A matter of personal preference. But my point here is that simplicity has its strong points. The primary purpose of the weapon considered is to rapidly engage targets in that 10 foot to 150 yard span. Have manufacturers been pushed by inflated need to market overly complex products? To me it seems apparent.
Colossians 3:17 (New King James Version) "And whatever you do in word or deed, do all in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through Him."
Obviously lots of choices for an AR scope mine is only for plinking & the occasional coyote / ground squirrel so my Burris ff2 is fine. For self defense I load number 4 & 5 heavy duck loads in a semi-auto 12 gauge. Perfectly deadly inside a room & no wall penetration to kill neighbors or family members. I’m pretty rural so it would be unlucky to hit an unintended person. Easy to do in a crowded urban environment- see KC parade shooting.
the Leupold VX6 1-6 that I own has a heavy duplex, I like the scope. Other than the power ring is too tight and I had to install a lever given to me by another fire member, I am very happy with it.