JB in SC,
Oh my God, you must have been heartbroken to lose a 25" German Brown, a fish of a lifetime, after being so close.
I just got back from Eagle Lake in Northern California pursuing the hard-fighting Eagle Lake trout. Some say they fight like steelhead, but I have never caught a steelie. Anyway, where big, hard-fighting fish roam is no place for light line.
I can get away with 4LB test in the High Sierra; however, every year more and more big fish, over 10 pounds, are landed. But I am slowly making transition to 6lb test as minimum. But for the most part, the fish are almost always well under two pounds, so 4lb will get 'er done. With that out of the way, I do know of lakes in the High Sierra that hold trout that will easily exceed 15 pounds. For these lakes I have a Stradic 4000 spooled with 10 pound test. I'd gladly pass up hundreds of pan-size trout for a decent chance at a fish of a lifetime!
There are many stores along or near US 395 that have mounted trout on walls that will conjure up thoughts of bent poles, taut lines, and screaming drags! I would love to be so lucky just once! If I were to be, I would want the right setup for the job.
Good fishin'
Leon