Home
Posted By: Tarkio Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/09/16
Fed Science Diet for years. Always felt it was worth it.

Now we have 5 dogs here and science diet prices have skyrocketed.

What's a good alternative?
Posted By: BamBam Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/09/16
www.dogfoodadvisor.com
I feed Diamond Natural Chicken and Rice.....about $35 for a 40# bag.....
I wouldn't know how it tastes. grin
Pro plan is what most serious dog guys use.
My vet told me Costco's food was good. Wish I knew.
Posted By: basdjs Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/09/16
Taste of the Wild has worked well for my English Cocker.
Posted By: jdm953 Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/09/16
4Health at Tractor Supply.No grain.
Posted By: broomd Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/09/16
Originally Posted by FieldGrade
I feed Diamond Natural Chicken and Rice.....about $35 for a 40# bag.....

Yep, great choice.
Victor makes great food free of fillers as well.

There is a reason some dogs live long lives. Our wirehaired griffons are almost 13 and 15 y/o respectively, their food is a huge reason why.

How people can throw Purina-type food full of artificially flavored and colored orange, green and red crap at their beloved pet is beyond me.
Posted By: ingwe Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/09/16
Originally Posted by Cariboujack
My vet told me Costco's food was good. Wish I knew.


I personally feed Eukanuba but when working the Canine Program at the college we had a Phd. on hand that worked in the dog food industry for 20 years.He recommended the Costco brand, and we fed it exclusively with no problems.( He was also a Veterinarian..)
Posted By: Beoceorl Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/09/16
Originally Posted by FieldGrade
I feed Diamond Natural Chicken and Rice.....about $35 for a 40# bag.....


Good stuff. We feed our Great Dane and Schnauzers the Lamb and Rice version.
Originally Posted by ingwe
Originally Posted by Cariboujack
My vet told me Costco's food was good. Wish I knew.


I personally feed Eukanuba but when working the Canine Program at the college we had a Phd. on hand that worked in the dog food industry for 20 years.He recommended the Costco brand, and we fed it exclusively with no problems.( He was also a Veterinarian..)


I've heard Costco's food is good....a couple of old field trialers I hunt with swear by it....
I stick with what I know....

Edit....I used to feed Pro Plan but my Cur dog has skin allergies and does better on the Diamond.....
Another vote for Pro Plan,I use the Focus chicken and rice formula
I feed Costco "Natures Domain" salmon and whatever. Good price and treats my dogs better than the Pro Plan I used to feed.

Posted By: SamOlson Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/09/16
Mini dogs get Hills Science diet and my dad's heeler gets Blue Wilderness.

That stuff is damn near $3/lb, should be just grilling them up pork chops and chicken!
Posted By: hanco Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/09/16
I fed all of my pointers Purina High Pro. It must not have hurt them too bad. Some of the Rebel bred dogs lasted 15 years. I had 8 to 10 dogs. I would buy a 1000 lb at a time. I kept it in an old ice cream box. I got a price break at that amount. Was a lot of dog crap to wash away.
feed my dogs Blue buffalo chicken and rice. They do fantastic on it. YMMV
Posted By: Steve Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/09/16
We feed the dog Costo's Nature's Domain. They've got about 5 types and try to buy a different one each time to prevent allergy generation.

So far no issues with our 6 yo lab.
Originally Posted by FieldGrade
I feed Diamond Natural Chicken and Rice.....about $35 for a 40# bag.....


We get the same stuff from Big R. was going to buy the Blue Buffalo stuff and was told about the Diamond. Exact same ingredients at a lower price. Guess it is the lack of advertising.
I think Diamond produces about 75% of the food out there. A lot is just branded different.

http://www.tasteofthewildpetfood.com

I get this at Tractor Supply or Southern States. It's good quality food and the dog loves it.
Canidae and Precise are the 2 I use for my dogs. I prefer the Canidae as the dogs don't each chicken shlt like they did with the Precise. Apparently Canidae has the RDA of chicken shlt. Stay away from the Costco crap. I know several people whose dogs had bad skin problems from Costco food. Once I recommended they switch foods the problems went away rapidly. There's corn mites and other crap in their food that a lot of (not all) dogs are sensitive to. Science diet and Blue Buffalo are good also. Both my dogs are the epitome of health and their coats are beautiful. I've had 2 different veterinarians tell me that my Lab is the healthiest and best looking Lab they've ever seen.
Posted By: hatari Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/09/16
Originally Posted by ingwe
Originally Posted by Cariboujack
My vet told me Costco's food was good. Wish I knew.


I personally feed Eukanuba but when working the Canine Program at the college we had a Phd. on hand that worked in the dog food industry for 20 years.He recommended the Costco brand, and we fed it exclusively with no problems.( He was also a Veterinarian..)


Chui,

The long time breeder of elkhounds we use (250 Best of Breed winners in 50+ years) instructed us to feed them Eukanuba the first year and Pedigree after. It has been good for us.
We fed our first dog-critter whatever Big Bear, TSC, or Farm Fleet had for cheap. Darned bugger was alive for 17 years and healthy for 16+; probably humped regularly through his 15th year. I hear tell that Red Paw is better if the dogs are working though.
Nutrisource super performance for my gun dogs.
Posted By: Autofive Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
Pro Plan
Posted By: mtnsnake Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
I feed my dogs Blue Buffalo Salmon dog food.
We go with the 4Health grain free from TS. Our golden that recently passed was allergic to the corn meal, which is loaded in most dog food. No problems whatsoever with the grain free.
Originally Posted by AcesNeights
Canidae and Precise are the 2 I use for my dogs. I prefer the Canidae as the dogs don't each chicken shlt like they did with the Precise. Apparently Canidae has the RDA of chicken shlt. Stay away from the Costco crap. I know several people whose dogs had bad skin problems from Costco food. Once I recommended they switch foods the problems went away rapidly. There's corn mites and other crap in their food that a lot of (not all) dogs are sensitive to. Science diet and Blue Buffalo are good also. Both my dogs are the epitome of health and their coats are beautiful. I've had 2 different veterinarians tell me that my Lab is the healthiest and best looking Lab they've ever seen.


Costco food is made at the same plant Canidae is made, so is Taste of the Wild. I feed my 2 parson russel terriers Canidae pure. They are both 7 years old and I have tried every imaginable dog food because one has really bad food allergies. They are both doing great, They have never had better coats and they have even more energy then before.

I also have a 11 month old Bull Mastiff puppy which is on Natures Domain by Costco. He has zero issues with it and he looks superb. I* might switch him to Taste of the Wild for a little more variety in his diet.

Best for your money and widely available is Diamond Naturals. I've hunted dogs four days a week throughout a the season off that. They do fine. Loyall Lamb and Rice is the same, but not quite as easy to get.
Posted By: ajmorell Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
We were feeding Blue Buffalo but switched to Eagle Pack 6 months or so ago. It's about $20/bag cheaper than BB for a 30lb bag.
Taste of the Wild
Posted By: Raeford Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
We switched from green bag Purina to Sportmix Wholesome Chicken or Lamb & rice from TSC. Our Lab was having continuous ear infections and the vet recommended getting away from grain based feeds. It seems to be helping though not 100%.
Averages about $30 for #40. But is 26% protein so I am feeding less than the 21% Purina.
Posted By: BarryC Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
Since we went grain free, our dogs don't eat their turds anymore.
Posted By: Gibby Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
Wellness Dog Food.


Turn your old dog to a puppy it will.
Posted By: 338Rem Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
Originally Posted by jdm953
4Health at Tractor Supply.No grain.


Switched to this and my Lab is doing great on it.
Posted By: Pappy348 Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
Let's see....

Kimber The Wonder Dog (Lab) eats three hot dogs, 3-6 dried chicken tenders (American not Chinese), a bowl of milk, three slices of American cheese, couple of large Milk Bones, a handful of Liva Snaps, occasionally a few crackers or cookies or Cheetos, and a can of Vienna sausages every day or so. He also like to lay in the grass and chew it down to the roots and then eat a little of the dirt for added flavor. Some nights he also eats a bag of Rise and Shine, that Play Doh-like stuff. Last down the hatch is a couple of rawhide strips, preferably chicken-flavored. He also is fond of almost any white bread, and cornbread, properly buttered of course.
Posted By: Paul4 Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
Merrick grain free. My dog is doing well on it. Started with blue wilderness as a pup and did well but lots of gas.
Posted By: mathman Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
Originally Posted by BarryC
Since we went grain free, our dogs don't eat their turds anymore.


Then Stevil should try a grain free diet too.
Posted By: Hotload Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
My GSD gets Pro Plan
Posted By: Wyogal Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
Pro Plan Sensitive skin and stomach Formula Salmon for my mutts.
I recently switched from Diamond Naturals to Taste of the Wild. If I remember correctly the bag of Taste of the Wild says Meta, MO on it. This would mean that it was made by Diamond also. Either way, both seem to be good to my labs.
Posted By: JimHnSTL Re: Looking for GOOD Dog food - 08/10/16
Originally Posted by Pappy348
Let's see....

Kimber The Wonder Dog (Lab) eats three hot dogs, 3-6 dried chicken tenders (American not Chinese), a bowl of milk, three slices of American cheese, couple of large Milk Bones, a handful of Liva Snaps, occasionally a few crackers or cookies or Cheetos, and a can of Vienna sausages every day or so. He also like to lay in the grass and chew it down to the roots and then eat a little of the dirt for added flavor. Some nights he also eats a bag of Rise and Shine, that Play Doh-like stuff. Last down the hatch is a couple of rawhide strips, preferably chicken-flavored. He also is fond of almost any white bread, and cornbread, properly buttered of course.


we must have had one of his siblings. regrettably she got put down about a year ago. best friend my kids ever had.
© 24hourcampfire