I'm thinking, if all goes well with my back surgery, I'll be ready to do some big game hunting next season, and thought I'd put in for archery elk.
Besides replaceable bladed heads like Thunderheads, I'm looking at these 3 types.
60 pounds should put any one of these, deep inside an elks chest.
Now, to choose which type ?
All are 100 grain.

Check out "Slick Trick" broadheads. Scary sharp and tough.

Which one ?

I used Thrunderheads for many years, I believe 125 gr.

Like Lonebull2, I use Slick Tricks now as well wicked sharp, extremely accurate with deep penetration. The GrizzTrick2 or The ViperTrick are great choices!

Check This Video out:

What makes them different from any other replacement blade broadhead ?
Muzzy's are good, Thunderheads have killed lots of critter for me.

Due to a shoulder issue I was using a 50# bow this fall w/ 355gr total arrows. Shot the same 100gr 3 blade Wack'ems that I have used for the last 2 years bull elk. Shot a cow broadside at 35 yards, arrow was a pass through and landed about 15 yards beyond. I have no reason to change.

Still hard to beat the old 3 blade Muzzy’s in my opinion. No telling how many hogs I’ve killed using one broad head over and over again. Even when they’re a little dull, they still work just fine. I’ve had lots of complete pass thru’s at 60 lbs with my old Matthews compound.
Once had 3 young hogs lined up perfectly under my bow feeder. Arrow zipped right through the 1st 2 pigs, and stopped in the 3rd pig. The broadhead and arrow was protruding through the offside of the 3rd pig by about 6 inches. Killed all 3 of them.
Most wouldn’t believe me if I hadn’t had a witness with me that day. My nephew was setting right beside me with a video cam. Unfortunately, the little dummy forgot to hit record. 🤪

Trochar tip.

All steel.

Or the solid three blade you have pictured on top.

Heavier arrows if possible.

U lose flatness of flight but penetration improves.

A good rangefinder , and using it , will alleviate most of the loss of flatter trajectory.

I don’t care 4 mechanical/ expandable heads.

I used the Muzzy 4 blade 90gr version for years on deer, elk and antelope here in Idaho. They worked just fine. My only complaint was getting them to spin straight. Sometimes it would take one broadhead on 3 or 4 different arrows before they would line up right. With the Wack'ems they seem to spin straight on my arrows on the first time. Both killed stuff just fine.

I have never had an issue with 100 grain Thunderheads, though I have only killed 3 elk and a moose with them. Not big mature bulls at that.

I am however a KISS person and went to fixed blade heads as any moving parts other than the head itself just doesn’t give the warm/fuzzy and doubly so on elk sized critters with heavy bones. Mechanicals supposedly have come a long ways but I still don’t have any confidence in them. Of those you show, I’d choose the first one assuming it shot well.

I went to NAP HellRazors but haven’t shot a darn thing with them yet. Iron Will, while not totally fixed and tooth if the arrow may make an appearance on my arrows here soon.

I just bought 6 of the first ones...

Splatter - If you have the time, check out the Ranch Fairy on YouTube. He's done a ton of research on arrow and broadhead effectiveness. He can sometimes rub people the wrong way (I find him hysterical personally) but it's worth your time to watch some of his stuff on shooting "adult" arrows IMHO.

Looking at the fixed blades I just bought brought back memories of a broadhead called a bodkin or something like that from my young days starting out.

Good move. They are the most accurate broad heads I’ve shot. Same POI as my field points. Killed a Black Bear this year with one. Completely broke the frond leg and shoulder and exited the carcass behind the other. Blade was not salvageable though as the tough bone bent one badly

I’ve used all that have been mentioned with good success. I’d call it a toss up between the Slick Tricks or Rage. My last hunt, I had both in the quiver (the Rage was for long shots in the wind as they drift less). If you have adequate arrow weight and a modern bow, either will provide more than enough penetration (assuming your using standard Rage). Just my .02.

Of the three you pictured, I’d take the Magnus Stinger for any big game in North America.

They remind me of the Bear Razorbacks if I remember what they were called. Killed a doe with one many moons ago.

FWIW I run 125gr heads, at the lightest.
Bit more FOC and that helps w tune IMHO.

Ive killed deer w the Montec and Stinger.
Bud needed some trad heads so gave him my Stingers, haven't seen any in shops since (figures).
Think the bleeder blade versions put more barn paint on the ground.

Am just a deer hunter though.

Match your BH to your setup.

A low energy setup benefits from an efficient BH.

I use that Stinger design- middle pic. …very effective, easy to BH tune then touch up, easy to reuse, lower effective cost per shot, but the #1 reason; animals dont react to being hit if you do your part…and most die in sight.

Those 2 blade heads slide in effortlessly Unlike some of the mechanicals or the short wide heads that get those animals moving like their tail is on fire- longer tracking jobs.

I Family had one animal in the last two years run out of sight while I was shooting the two blade heads….. And that was one of those jumpy Coues deer bucks. That arrow hit him quartering away and Broke the offside shoulder with the Broadhead sticking 6 inches out in front. He didnt go far.

Of the 3 you posted, I would choose #2 which looks like a Magnus Stinger. I have seen 3 elk fall to those heads and they do a lot of damage. I personally use the QAD Exodus for a few reasons. Shot a very small bull with a trypan a few years ago. Awful results and never again will I use mechanical heads on an elk.

Get both lungs and any broadhead will work. Don’t get both lungs and the odds are the elk will not be recovered.

I'll be getting the stinger looking broadheads too. I'll figure out what flies best.
400 spine, 2" vane arrows in bound, and checking out automatic lighted arrow knocks. Says adds 20 grains to arrow weight.
Sure hope I bounce back from back surgery to enjoy archery again...

the last elk bulls and cows son and i have shot were with Elmer heads now called Sevr this is an expandable head and works very well ,i have in the past used other expandable broadheads they did not kill the bulls that fast . my 1st bull was with a Zwickey Eskimo 125 gr. that broadhead is a great cut on impact if you shoot a slower bow and have the ability to sharpen a broadhead . good luck , Pete53

Got those broadheads in and sharpness is a bit to be desired.
Took a diamond sharpener to one, and it's better, but not hair shaving sharp.
I think I'll go back to what I used years ago.
A thunderhead, 100gr this time tho.
Those blades are sharp.

+1, no broadhead will make up for poor shot placement. Broadside or quartering away only for me.

Slick Tricks are RAZOR SHARP out of the package, they fly "as straight as an arrow" lol

The arrows I use with them are Gold Tip Kenetic XT 300. I shoot with an older bow a Darton Vaper and FPS is around 290-300. Great Broadhead - Arrow combination.

KB

Slick trick magnums are the best! And they aren't super expensive. I've killed two bulls with them, and they have performed flawlessly.

Hi firstcoueswas80, isn't it amazing how pure they fly? Never seen a broadhead so accurate, dependable and deadly, with zero spin in flight.

KB

It really is. They are nuts!