Home
Posted By: Oldman03 Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
I've always wondered if the DNA testing sites, like '23 and Me' or 'Ancestry.com' and there are several others, were private. Well, I got my answer today.

The link below is an article about a Washington woman that has been missing for 40 years. The authorities used DNA and cross referenced it with DNA from commercial sites to identify the woman's remains.

So, not only do you get your results from your DNA tests, so do the feds. Now I figure that just being on the campfire is enough for the feds to keep an eye on me/us, but voluntarily giving them my DNA is not my cup of tea.

https://www.yahoo.com/news/spokane-woman-missing-nearly-40-020200928.html
Posted By: CrowRifle Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
I work for the lab that runs the assay for one of the top players in DNA testing.

Trust me when I say that nothing about genetic testing is private. You put your genome in the public arena when you are tested and it stays there for ever.
Posted By: akasparky Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Actually it could have a up side, sorta like chipping your dog.

After we all grow old and feeble and get hard of hearing and decide to take a walk, if some cop a half a block away screams 'drop the cane and eat dirt' and we refuse, because we can't fckin hear him..

They can sop up some of your blood from the street after they gun you down and be able to find out who you belonged to.
Posted By: hanco Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
We had ours done. I was supposed to have American Indian in me, nope, English, Scandinavian, 6% Italian, and 1% Chinese.
Wifey is the same, except 6% Middle Eastern. She found out she is 3rd or 4th cousins to Rhett Akins from her Dad’s side.

They have caught a few criminals that were floating underground through their kin that had the DNA testing done. I don’t break the law, so I’m not worried about the government having mine.
Posted By: Stickfight Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
One of the founders and current CEO of 23andMe is Anne Wojcicki, who is a Jew.

A universal truth about Jews is that if you give them the opportunity, they will Jew you. So you have to deny them those opportunities if you want to avoid that certain outcome.
Posted By: kaywoodie Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by hanco
We had ours done. I was supposed to have American Indian in me, nope, English, Scandinavian, 6% Italian, and 1% Chinese.
Wifey is the same, except 6% Middle Eastern. She found out she is 3rd or 4th cousins to Rhett Akins from her Dad’s side.

They have caught a few criminals that were floating underground through their kin that had the DNA testing done. I don’t break the law, so I’m not worried about the government having mine.


Hanco,

You’ve already broke the law. You are white!!!
Posted By: smokepole Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
A white man from Texas no less. Gotta be a supremacist.
Posted By: Dutch Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Micheal Connolly’s novel “Fair Warning” from last year explored some of the issues around data in the testing industry. Hint: they aren’t making their money on the $20 they charge you.

Like with Facebook, if you aren’t the customer, you are the product.
Posted By: mjbgalt Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
As for the native American DNA...i have 100 percent proof I am 1/8 Sioux and the ancestry test came back not mentioning that. I did a little digging and it seems the tribes told them no way when it came to giving them samples to use.

So it sounds like their tests are not as accurate as they want us to think. It's only as accurate as the data they have to work with like any other piece of science.
Posted By: Esox357 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Its a database.....and people are dumb enough to pay to use it.
Posted By: MIKEWERNER Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
You've been trained well.

Originally Posted by hanco
I don’t break the law, so I’m not worried about the government........
Originally Posted by hanco
I don’t break the law, so I’m not worried about the government having mine.


I'll take words that tyrants love for $1000 Alex...
Posted By: 673 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
What's the problem if you're DNA is known to other's?...
20+ yrs ago, without thinking, I gave a sample for an insurance policy, would like to walk that back.

It could be used for good if they can identify unsolved cases, victim's and perp's can be identified.
Posted By: Esox357 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Why in the fug would anyone need or want your DNA, is the question!
Posted By: kaywoodie Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by mjbgalt
As for the native American DNA...i have 100 percent proof I am 1/8 Sioux and the ancestry test came back not mentioning that. I did a little digging and it seems the tribes told them no way when it came to giving them samples to use.

So it sounds like their tests are not as accurate as they want us to think. It's only as accurate as the data they have to work with like any other piece of science.


It’s not that their tests aren’t accurate, it has to do with them not exactly reporting the complete story. Had a bit of a conversation with archaeologist son on this very subject. He occasionally gets involved in a bunch of DNA work thru his employment.
He said something like that a bunch of folks are doing the test specifically to see if they have any NA DNA. As we was a bit of drinking involved during this discussion I will try to explain the best I remember. He stated that if the numbers are low, as would be the case in many circumstances, they go unreported. So unless it is quite obvious that you have NA DNA, they are more or less, adhering to an agenda.

I know that my good childhood bud (now deceased), stated that his results showed small “Mongolian” traces. So that may be one method of Skirting the issue.

Also there is always the possibility that being so miniscule and watered down, the NA DNA was simply not passed to a person.

Son went on to say this was a method to keep caucasians from claiming NA descent. He also said you can asked to have it checked and some companies will come clean and give you nimbers.

Now I may be totally full of schidt. And admit it. But something along these lines is the best way I remember the conversation. He’s is convinced that any NA traces our family may have are just not there. Despite the same old family stories. But he went on to state that did not mean they weren't there in past great grandparents etc

Like I said, this is the best I remember. Anyone else heard any of this???
Posted By: simonkenton7 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
I paid a hundred bucks to get on to 23andme.com Well worth it.

What I like the most is I found out that I have more Neanderthal DNA than 96 percent of the population.



[Linked Image from i.imgur.com]
Posted By: Dess Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by 673
What's the problem if you're DNA is known to other's?...
20+ yrs ago, without thinking, I gave a sample for an insurance policy, would like to walk that back.

It could be used for good if they can identify unsolved cases, victim's and perp's can be identified.



I agree. A useful tool is turned against the innocent and used as a weapon, I fear the company/government in its abuse and privacy issues.

Same thing happened at work with GPS on company vehicles. Useful for dispatching, but some managers were glued to the computer screen looking for route violations when a guy needed a bathroom break.
Posted By: mjbgalt Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Ancestry admitted it in fine print on their site when I did some digging. In my case my grandmothers mother was 1/2 sioux and we have relics and other proof of this. So in my case I didn't take the test to find that out. I was trying to trace mom's side.

Kinda stupid that they even manipulate who you are.
Posted By: deflave Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Government wants to database as much DNA as possible.

Volunteers help.
Posted By: MIKEWERNER Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Does anyone honestly believe politicians are heart-broken over C19 wiping out certain low-income nursing homes?

Suppose these politicians have a way to determine who is predisposed to the most costly long term elderly care.

Financial class, as well, in determination.

Some folks just don't deserve a long life.

Think Barack and Obamacare.....giving granny a pain pill instead of a new hip.......then sending her out on the ice to fetch the mail.
Posted By: Dess Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
The Germans were obsessed with knowing your ancestry and genetics to keep the race "pure". All the DNA stuff could be very dangerous in the wrong hands.

They used to plant a weapon as evidence at a crime scene to frame the innocent. Now the unscrupulous need only a sample of your DNA. Scary.
Posted By: kaywoodie Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Have a good bud who is the cultural resource officer for the Oklahoma Seminole Nation. He said several years ago the feds did some financial settlements with the Oklahoma Seminoles. $$$$$. He went on to say you should have see who came out of the woodworks claiming membership. And they weren’t caucasian.

Now He went on to say that there were a few legit claims. But on the whole most were there for da money they thought they would get.
Posted By: Old_Toot Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by kaywoodie
Have a good bud who is the cultural resource officer for the Oklahoma Seminole Nation. He said several years ago the feds did some financial settlements with the Oklahoma Seminoles. $$$$$. He went on to say you should have see who came out of the woodworks claiming membership. And they weren’t caucasian.

Now He went on to say that there were a few legit claims. But on the whole most were there for da money they thought they would get.


Exactly the same for the Indian Casinos in Louisiana.

Never knew that we had so many native Americans in Louisiana.
Posted By: 673 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Regarding indian nation's of North America....last time I checked they are not all of the same DNA, very interesting.
Posted By: stxhunter Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Mine was 23% NA, my wife 54%.
Posted By: 673 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
I wonder which is the best place to go for a legitimate DNA inquiry?
Posted By: Joezone Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by mjbgalt
As for the native American DNA...i have 100 percent proof I am 1/8 Sioux and the ancestry test came back not mentioning that. I did a little digging and it seems the tribes told them no way when it came to giving them samples to use.

So it sounds like their tests are not as accurate as they want us to think. It's only as accurate as the data they have to work with like any other piece of science.


DNA doesn't get passed on in direct proportion to your ancestry, in other words if one of your 8 great grandparents was 100% Sioux, that doesn't mean that 1/8 of your DNA would be Sioux. I have distant ancestors from the Delaware tribe but no DNA from that line, while one of my sisters does have DNA from them. Actual inherited DNA is pretty random and siblings will often have quite a different mix of DNA.
Posted By: Joezone Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by Esox357
Why in the fug would anyone need or want your DNA, is the question!


China will be trying to steal it from Olympic competitors. Think genetic engineering, and bio weapons.
Posted By: Esox357 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Absolutely. I was being somewhat facetious.
Posted By: deflave Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by 673
I wonder which is the best place to go for a legitimate DNA inquiry?


Nowhere.
Posted By: deflave Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by Joezone
Originally Posted by Esox357
Why in the fug would anyone need or want your DNA, is the question!


China will be trying to steal it from Olympic competitors. Think genetic engineering, and bio weapons.


Uhhh, no.

Think finding you more easily.
Posted By: deflave Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
14 states mandate DNA collection for all felony arrests.

9 for misdemeanors.

100% of illegal aliens are swabbed.

The right tends to be as excited about it as the left.
Posted By: deflave Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by stxhunter
Mine was 23% NA, my wife 54%.


Certainly explains the house full of kids and a pet fox.
Posted By: Huntz Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Found out I belong to the Fugowee tribe.
Posted By: bruinruin Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by Esox357
Its a database.....and people are dumb enough to pay to use it.

Wouldn't surprise me to someday learn that .gov has been secretly funding these sites all along.
Posted By: MadMooner Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
My DNA was taken about 20 years ago by the po-po.

I've no doubt it'll reside in the database long after I'm gone.
Originally Posted by CrowRifle
I work for the lab that runs the assay for one of the top players in DNA testing.

Trust me when I say that nothing about genetic testing is private. You put your genome in the public arena when you are tested and it stays there for ever.


can you buy samples of other people's DNA?

(asking for a friend)
Posted By: simonkenton7 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Some of y'all boys are a little paranoid. I joined 23andme.com five years ago and never gave it a second thought.

I wonder how long y'all give me, until the FBI and the CIA kick down my door.
Posted By: WMR Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
An extensive DNA database would be a treasure trove of info to insurance companies, employers and marketers. Actually, the possibilities are endless. Compared to these people, government folks are rank amateurs.
Posted By: Rock Chuck Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Ancestery.com solved a long time family legend for us. It was believed that we had either some Cherokee or Freedman Cherokee in the family. Neither showed up.
Posted By: MadMooner Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Folks have long signed up at grocery stores for "member discounts".

They can track what you purchase. Always figured insurance companies would be interested in folks diets and alcohol/tobacco habits.
Posted By: FatCity67 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Never would have caught the Golden State Killer before he died.

Posted By: Dess Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Markers in your DNA for many hereditary issues are already known. I see a time when insurance companies will raise your rates or deny coverage regardless of any symptoms or actual sickness.
Posted By: Idaho_Shooter Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Wife's Granny was half blood Cherokee, born and raised on the reservation.

Makes the wife 1/8 Cherokee.

Her sister, always one to do whatever she hears the yuppies are doing, and trying to be one of the cool kids, sent in a DNA sample.

Her results came back @ about 3% NA.

But it is common knowledge that the NA DNA of the Cherokee Nation had been diluted over a couple of centuries before they hit the Trail of Tears.

Those blue eyes did not come across the Bering Strait.
Posted By: simonkenton7 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by FatCity67
Never would have caught the Golden State Killer before he died.



Yes, you are right, that psycho murdered 11 people and he raped about 40 women. And, he was a cop at the time! They caught him because some of his 3rd cousins put their DNA on 23andme.com
Forty years had passed since his last crime, talk about a cold case, and they never would have caught him without the DNA.
I never raped or murdered anyone so I am not worried but if there is a psycho in my family and my dna helps catch him, that would be just fine with me.
Posted By: MIKEWERNER Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
You forgot to mention you have no problem kneeling before your rulers.

Originally Posted by simonkenton7

I never raped or murdered anyone so I am not worried........
Posted By: rte Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by hanco
We had ours done. I was supposed to have American Indian in me, nope, English, Scandinavian, 6% Italian, and 1% Chinese.
Wifey is the same, except 6% Middle Eastern. She found out she is 3rd or 4th cousins to Rhett Akins from her Dad’s side.

They have caught a few criminals that were floating underground through their kin that had the DNA testing done. I don’t break the law, so I’m not worried about the government having mine.


Haahaha! Naivete.

That's analogous to stating, I don't break the law,so I'm not worried about gun registration.
Posted By: Oldman03 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Read this before you put much faith in the pay-n-play DNA test....

https://www.healthyway.com/content/...ked-to-learn-that-their-dna-didnt-match/
Posted By: FatCity67 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by simonkenton7
Originally Posted by FatCity67
Never would have caught the Golden State Killer before he died.



Yes, you are right, that psycho murdered 11 people and he raped about 40 women. And, he was a cop at the time! They caught him because some of his 3rd cousins put their DNA on 23andme.com
Forty years had passed since his last crime, talk about a cold case, and they never would have caught him without the DNA.
I never raped or murdered anyone so I am not worried but if there is a psycho in my family and my dna helps catch him, that would be just fine with me.


I know the story well. He struck in our neighborhood in Stockton Ca. and in Rancho Cordova a couple houses down from my Aunt and Uncle's home. Couple years apart in the mid to late 70's.
Posted By: simonkenton7 Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/11/21
Originally Posted by MIKEWERNER
You forgot to mention you have no problem kneeling before your rulers.

Originally Posted by simonkenton7

I never raped or murdered anyone so I am not worried........



The "rulers" didn't order me to join 23andme.com It was completely voluntary, and I have not regretted it and would do it again. It is surprising to me the way guys on this forum can take an innocuous activity and find something negative about it. Happens on just about every thread. Y'all negative and paranoid boys need to remember the song, it was written for guys like you...

"Paranoia strikes deep
In to your lives it will creep
Starts when you're always afraid
Step out of line, the man comes, and takes you away..."
Posted By: MIKEWERNER Re: Commercial DNA sites - 05/12/21
Obviously.......the COVID sham and the ‘irregularities’ of the last election has taught you nothing.

Originally Posted by simonkenton7
Originally Posted by MIKEWERNER
You forgot to mention you have no problem kneeling before your rulers.

Originally Posted by simonkenton7

I never raped or murdered anyone so I am not worried........



The "rulers" didn't order me to join 23andme.com It was completely voluntary, and I have not regretted it and would do it again. It is surprising to me the way guys on this forum can take an innocuous activity and find something negative about it. Happens on just about every thread. Y'all negative and paranoid boys need to remember the song, it was written for guys like you...

"Paranoia strikes deep
In to your lives it will creep
Starts when you're always afraid
Step out of line, the man comes, and takes you away..."
© 24hourcampfire