First off I don't agree with any of this especially "Red Flag" laws but when this story first came out a few days ago it came out as a red flag order had been signed so I don't know if this particular story is true or if the other story is true.
As far as the law goes if a red flag order was in force the cop was following the law as written, if it wasn't he violated the mans civil rights and needs to be removed from office.
From one of the original news stories on this it sounds like there was no red flag order issued by the court.
It sounds like the police chief did this all on his own.
https://www.mvtimes.com/2019/10/11/...pO_jtkC8VUC1grGXNwPuB8t2E9H4qYt4EEJg_6h8Nichols said he was unimpressed with the Tisbury School resource officer’s alleged trips to Xtra Mart to get coffee when children came to school in the morning. While dining at Linda Jean’s a couple of weeks ago, Nichols said he told a friend about this and suggested somebody could “shoot up the school” in that officer’s absence, which he described as “leaving his post.”
Nichols said the waitress made a complaint to Tisbury Police about what she overheard and on the strength of that, Saloio and another officer relieved Nichols of his crossing guard duties while he was in the midst of performing them and subsequently drove to his home and took away his firearms license and guns.
“He came up and told me what I said was a felony but he wasn’t going to charge me,” Nichols said of Saloio.
The confiscated guns were later turned over to Nichols’ son-in-law, Nichols told The Times.
Asked if he was given a letter or any paperwork for the seizure of his license, Nichols said,
“No he just told me to hand it over so I took it out of my wallet and handed it to him.”