Home
Saw this article on AllOutdoor today and figured it worthy of discussion here.

I always carry 1 extra magazine. Used to carry 2 in a mag holster, but that got to feeling like a duty belt. Made me understand why cops always walk with their elbows out. laugh

Interested in knowing what everybody else does. ??
Yessir, always carry at least two hi-cap mags, and sometimes three of the 8 round single stacks 45's or 10 round Tripp 10mm and 38 Super mags, they all ride perfectly comfortable in my rear left jeans pocket, a tin of Cope keeps em all standing up straight and handy. grin
It's pretty easy to carry a second mag so the question should be why not.
Originally Posted by RufusG
It's pretty easy to carry a second mag so the question should be why not.

Just that much more weight pulling your pants down. A loaded 17 round magazine is pretty heavy in the pocket. With 18 on board the Glock 17 already, I don't particularly feel the need for it, coming from my last CCW which was a six shot .38. That's three times the firepower without a reload. It's like a Model 10 with two speed loaders, except you don't need to speed load them.

Now, when I carry the Glock 43 instead, I almost always carry a spare mag in my pants pocket, because those, fully loaded, aren't very heavy.

Of course there's always an extra loaded 17 round Glock mag somewhere nearby, such as in the night stand drawer, or glove compartment of my car, which can easily be grabbed and stuck in a pocket if the need arises.
I don't carry any spare mags.
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by RufusG
It's pretty easy to carry a second mag so the question should be why not.

Just that much more weight pulling your pants down. A loaded 17 round magazine is pretty heavy in the pocket. With 18 on board the Glock 17 already, I don't particularly feel the need for it, coming from my last CCW which was a six shot .38. That's three times the firepower without a reload. It's like a Model 10 with two speed loaders, except you don't need to speed load them.

Now, when I carry the Glock 43 instead, I almost always carry a spare mag in my pants pocket, because those, fully loaded, aren't very heavy.

Of course there's always an extra loaded 17 round Glock mag somewhere nearby, such as in the night stand drawer, or glove compartment of my car, which can easily be grabbed and stuck in a pocket if the need arises.


Weight should never be a concern with staying alive, there isn't a swinging dick on here that hasn't begged, connived, pleaded, hoodwinked his way into gladly hoisting a 120lb woman up in the shower and hammering himself stupid! and will every damn chance he gets.

Carrying extra ammo could be the difference in getting to do that again, not to mention being alive to watch out for that woman and kids for the remainder of your life, the Copper gun thread about so many NOT carrying damn near put me in a ""stupid"" coma, and that doesn't take much btw. crazy comfort? fu-k comfort, stay alive, rest when you get back to the damn house.
Originally Posted by gunner500

Weight should never be a concern with staying alive, there isn't a swinging dick on here that hasn't begged, connived, pleaded, hoodwinked his way into gladly hoisting a 120lb woman up in the shower and hammering himself stupid! and will every damn chance he gets.

Carrying extra ammo could be the difference in getting to do that again, not to mention being alive to watch out for that woman and kids for the remainder of your life, the Copper gun thread about so many NOT carrying damn near put me in a ""stupid"" coma, and that doesn't take much btw. crazy comfort? fu-k comfort, stay alive, rest when you get back to the damn house.



Are you 12 years old?
I carry a revolver----so yes a couple speed loaders.
Somebody's been watchin' too many action movies.
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by RufusG
It's pretty easy to carry a second mag so the question should be why not.

Just that much more weight pulling your pants down.


Well, stop wearing those gang-banger pants halfway down your ass. 😆
2 is one and one is none! always carry a reload, always! Cuz you just never know!
I don't generally carry a spare mag for the Glock 17.

Lot's of good reasons to do so...………..but I like living on the edge.....grin
No, if I carry a revolver sometimes not always I will carry five or six rounds in my front pocket .
Originally Posted by RufusG
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by RufusG
It's pretty easy to carry a second mag so the question should be why not.

Just that much more weight pulling your pants down.


Well, stop wearing those gang-banger pants halfway down your ass. 😆

LOL. grin
I wear these suspenders every day. They are strong, and do not get in the way of where I put my holster (strongside or stong side behind hip bone). They keep everything riding where it should be.

https://www.duluthtrading.com/mens-contractor-suspenders-91236.html
I carry 2 spare 12 rounders for my Sig P365. Always.
I can't think of a single instance where I'd want to be engaging someone with three hi-cap magazines worth of ammo.
If I was down by the southern border, I'd be rolling heavy too. Here in MT, it's a little different.
I carry a 15 round 2.0 M&P Compact IWB and carry an extra 15 round mag on my belt in a BFG Ten Speed pouch horizontally. Along with my wallet, keys, flashlight, knife and spare change in my pockets and my pants haven't fell down yet.

It's not so much the number of rounds, cause I carry a J frame at times with a speed strip.

One shot might be all it takes or the magazine in the gun might break, heck I locked up a J frame once in a match. Murphy is out there.
J frame in my front pocket. Usually a speed strip or two in my back pocket. Hasbeen
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
If I was down by the southern border, I'd be rolling heavy too. Here in MT, it's a little different.


Don't get me wrong, if I'm schit kicking in the woods or mountains I carry a healthy amount of ammo.

But for day in and day out just going to store or whatever, I just don't see where Joe Schit the Ragman is going to be well served by engaging anything with 50 rounds of ammo. If anything it will just get you shot by the po-po.

I think a "fire and flee" approach makes more sense.
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
I wear these suspenders every day. They are strong, and do not get in the way of where I put my holster (strongside or stong side behind hip bone). They keep everything riding where it should be.

https://www.duluthtrading.com/mens-contractor-suspenders-91236.html

Yeah, but what if I don't want to look like a doofus? grin

[Linked Image]
I never carry a spare mag, if my loaded CCW doesn't do the job it's time to back out.
Yes! Two is better yet! memtb
I carry a spare mag, mainly because mag-related malfunctions are the most likely thing to cause a problem. I understand why some prefer to carry more than 1 spare although I don't myself. I don't see any good reason not to carry at least one; stuff happens we can't predict, and having a spare is no hindrance to my everyday life.
Originally Posted by deflave
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
If I was down by the southern border, I'd be rolling heavy too. Here in MT, it's a little different.


Don't get me wrong, if I'm schit kicking in the woods or mountains I carry a healthy amount of ammo.

But for day in and day out just going to store or whatever, I just don't see where Joe Schit the Ragman is going to be well served by engaging anything with 50 rounds of ammo. If anything it will just get you shot by the po-po.

I think a "fire and flee" approach makes more sense.



“Fire and Flee”, is a good plan! That “back-up” magazine may provide you with the “fire” to accomplish that! Just a thought! memtb
Originally Posted by Yondering
I carry a spare mag, mainly because mag-related malfunctions are the most likely thing to cause a problem. I understand why some prefer to carry more than 1 spare although I don't myself. I don't see any good reason not to carry at least one; stuff happens we can't predict, and having a spare is no hindrance to my everyday life.


Good point.
Originally Posted by memtb
Originally Posted by deflave
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
If I was down by the southern border, I'd be rolling heavy too. Here in MT, it's a little different.


Don't get me wrong, if I'm schit kicking in the woods or mountains I carry a healthy amount of ammo.

But for day in and day out just going to store or whatever, I just don't see where Joe Schit the Ragman is going to be well served by engaging anything with 50 rounds of ammo. If anything it will just get you shot by the po-po.

I think a "fire and flee" approach makes more sense.



“Fire and Flee”, is a good plan! That “back-up” magazine may provide you with the “fire” to accomplish that! Just a thought! memtb


Or the opportunity to top off your gun for plausible deniability.😇
Reloading is one thing.

Reloading twice is quite another.
Originally Posted by chlinstructor
Originally Posted by Yondering
I carry a spare mag, mainly because mag-related malfunctions are the most likely thing to cause a problem. I understand why some prefer to carry more than 1 spare although I don't myself. I don't see any good reason not to carry at least one; stuff happens we can't predict, and having a spare is no hindrance to my everyday life.


Good point.


No.

It really ain’t a good point.

Who the fugk is walking around with a mag that induces malfunctions in their carry weapon? How often does this occur?
Rarely...

Have been studying gunfights, both LE and civilian, since the early 1980s. From the stats I have seen LE ends up with a reload in about 7% of their gun fights. Civilians....0.00001%.

I've asked most of the big name trainers if they have examples of a civilian reload where shots were fired after the reload...none. Or run out of ammo and a reload could have been done if available and ended up injured or dead...none. I've seen a couple of accounts of reloading but hard to verify...

In Tom Givins book FIGHTING SMARTER he had over 60 students in gunfights and not a one needed a reload. He said a couple topped off after the fight was over but it didn't change the outcome any...

That said, I do carry a ManBag that has my checkbook wallet, sunglasses case, and a bunch of other small stuff that I don't want stuffed in my pockets or used to be on me when I wore a vest. There is a extra magazine in there.

Bob
The only time it is HABIT,is when schlepping something with a mag disconnect safety...which means S&W 41's.

Hint..................
Originally Posted by deflave
Originally Posted by chlinstructor
Originally Posted by Yondering
I carry a spare mag, mainly because mag-related malfunctions are the most likely thing to cause a problem. I understand why some prefer to carry more than 1 spare although I don't myself. I don't see any good reason not to carry at least one; stuff happens we can't predict, and having a spare is no hindrance to my everyday life.


Good point.


No.

It really ain’t a good point.

Who the fugk is walking around with a mag that induces malfunctions in their carry weapon? How often does this occur?



At least I won’t have to “flee” like you! 😜
Originally Posted by chlinstructor
Originally Posted by deflave
Originally Posted by chlinstructor
Originally Posted by Yondering
I carry a spare mag, mainly because mag-related malfunctions are the most likely thing to cause a problem. I understand why some prefer to carry more than 1 spare although I don't myself. I don't see any good reason not to carry at least one; stuff happens we can't predict, and having a spare is no hindrance to my everyday life.


Good point.


No.

It really ain’t a good point.

Who the fugk is walking around with a mag that induces malfunctions in their carry weapon? How often does this occur?



At least I won’t have to “flee” like you! 😜


Thinking if you can't get the job done in 15 rounds, you damn well better flee.


And I'd like to see those stories of confirmed proper mags failing in a gunfight.
Originally Posted by deflave
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
If I was down by the southern border, I'd be rolling heavy too. Here in MT, it's a little different.


Don't get me wrong, if I'm schit kicking in the woods or mountains I carry a healthy amount of ammo.

But for day in and day out just going to store or whatever, I just don't see where Joe Schit the Ragman is going to be well served by engaging anything with 50 rounds of ammo. If anything it will just get you shot by the po-po.

I think a "fire and flee" approach makes more sense.




The decision is almost always situational.

I'm sure most of us do a conscious or subconscious threat assessment every time we are heading out the door.
Originally Posted by deflave


Don't get me wrong, if I'm schit kicking in the woods or mountains I carry a healthy amount of ammo.

But for day in and day out just going to store or whatever, I just don't see where Joe Schit the Ragman is going to be well served by engaging anything with 50 rounds of ammo. If anything it will just get you shot by the po-po.

I think a "fire and flee" approach makes more sense.

Well put. (Insult would normally go here).
The only time I've ever thought that I might come in 2nd Place,was on Chichagof. Had (5) Brownies in proximity,the furthest being 20yds away. (2) Boars to my left and a Sow and Twins to my right,post Rut(luckily).

I KNEW someone would find the Satin Nickle BHP in my mitts emptied,but really didn't know what the Final Score was gonna read.(grin)

An extry mag(which I had on me at the time),wasn't gonna "help" and I luckily managed to slip away,less pressing the trigger.

Woulda made a nice video.

Hint....................(grin)
Originally Posted by chlinstructor


At least I won’t have to “flee” like you! 😜


Ah the old "Mall Ninja" mentality appears! At this point one of the resident Mall Ninjas will chime in telling us how they always carry three 30 round spare mags for their Glock 26 and practice mag changes using their anus.

I'd never admit to carrying a "manbag" on this site......never.
Originally Posted by chlinstructor


At least I won’t have to “flee” like you! 😜


Hope your lawyer ain't a gentile.
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
I don't generally carry a spare mag for the Glock 17.

Lot's of good reasons to do so...………..but I like living on the edge.....grin

I've met you - bad asses don't need no spare mags grin
Originally Posted by FieldGrade
I'd never admit to carrying a "manbag" on this site......never.



Tough to beat a Satchel.

Hint.............

[Linked Image]
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
I wear these suspenders every day. They are strong, and do not get in the way of where I put my holster (strongside or stong side behind hip bone). They keep everything riding where it should be.

https://www.duluthtrading.com/mens-contractor-suspenders-91236.html

Yeah, but what if I don't want to look like a doofus? grin

...and you obviously have not met the man grin
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
I wear these suspenders every day. They are strong, and do not get in the way of where I put my holster (strongside or stong side behind hip bone). They keep everything riding where it should be.

https://www.duluthtrading.com/mens-contractor-suspenders-91236.html




No Jethro jokes from your local co-constuents? laugh
Originally Posted by local_dirt
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
I wear these suspenders every day. They are strong, and do not get in the way of where I put my holster (strongside or stong side behind hip bone). They keep everything riding where it should be.

https://www.duluthtrading.com/mens-contractor-suspenders-91236.html




No Jethro jokes from your local co-constuents? laugh


Naah, Jethro used a rope to keep his pants up!
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
If I was down by the southern border, I'd be rolling heavy too. Here in MT, it's a little different.


That's probably the best answer.

Everybody's situation is different.
Originally Posted by FieldGrade
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
If I was down by the southern border, I'd be rolling heavy too. Here in MT, it's a little different.


That's probably the best answer.

Everybody's situation is different.


I’m a long ways from the border. Unfortunately they all pass by me on their way North. Some even stay. Hasbeen
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
I wear these suspenders every day. They are strong, and do not get in the way of where I put my holster (strongside or stong side behind hip bone). They keep everything riding where it should be.

https://www.duluthtrading.com/mens-contractor-suspenders-91236.html

Yeah, but what if I don't want to look like a doofus? grin

[Linked Image]



That's easy....just don't walk around with a just-fu-cked-the-neighbors-cat grin on your face...…….grin
Originally Posted by local_dirt
Saw this article on AllOutdoor today and figured it worthy of discussion here.

I always carry 1 extra magazine. Used to carry 2 in a mag holster, but that got to feeling like a duty belt. Made me understand why cops always walk with their elbows out. laugh

Interested in knowing what everybody else does. ??



Yes. At least one reload.

A person would feel pretty silly when the nutcuttin' came, and he ran out of ammo at a critical time. wink
Enjoyed the thread, made me think and laugh. Lotta good points around where I live they say plausible combat range is 7-12 yds, shooting at anyone past that will get you looked at real hard by the law (why didn't you retreat?) Deflaves point. Guess it should most likely come down to what you think you might have to take on ,worst case scenario. Hard enough to carry a full size ccw without it being obvious, never mind 2-3 extra mags. Sometimes I carry a DAO M60 SW 38 and others a CZ semi auto in 9 or 40. I was a boy scout once half a century a go, never did forget "be prepared". Guess that is why I carry a AR and a pump gun in the truck as well. Truck all ways seems to have more ammo in it than all these arsenals some criminal has. No matter what you got, the liberals will still fault you for standing up against some perp. WTF after the first shot the rest are free right? Carry what you can easily conceal, out sight, out of mind. Do what you gotta when the time comes. trust your self and don't worry about what anyone else does. MB
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Originally Posted by deflave
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
If I was down by the southern border, I'd be rolling heavy too. Here in MT, it's a little different.


Don't get me wrong, if I'm schit kicking in the woods or mountains I carry a healthy amount of ammo.

But for day in and day out just going to store or whatever, I just don't see where Joe Schit the Ragman is going to be well served by engaging anything with 50 rounds of ammo. If anything it will just get you shot by the po-po.

I think a "fire and flee" approach makes more sense.




The decision is almost always situational.

I'm sure most of us do a conscious or subconscious threat assessment every time we are heading out the door.


you pretty much got it down, it is situational. overlooking the issue with semiautomatics, and a jam or malfunction, most likely rare, is the issue of multiple targets with various degrees of threat. We were practicing that clear back in the 70's, when everyone was using six shot revolvers.
i did have a situation one time with about ten or so armed very drunk bikers, that another guy and i had to arrest. I would have liked to have had a MP5. And i do live near the border, which is everywhere these days in arizona, with phoenix being one of the major transit points for narco's.
and i have come across large groups of illegals with coyotes on the desert.
Given that situation i always had some kind of black rifle in the truck, and both extra mags for it and the sidearm.
There was a local situation in prescott just last weekend where a man and wife, unarmed, got jumped by four people described as hispanics.
The man got the snot kicked out of him.
whatever makes you comfortable.
I felt comfortable for years with a model 19 and some speed loaders, still do to some extent. But those high cap mags are there for a reason.
I had to go to a court proceeding a few years ago, one of the armed guys in the courthouse was packing a mag holder for four spare mags.
i was kind of snickering at that, but not so much anymore.
i shouldd add it is much different shooting paper targets than having a firearm pointed at somebody knowing that somebody might be meeting eternity shortly. You get pretty wired up. Which is the reason you hear of some cops dumping a whole magazine out of that glock 17.
Chit! I wear my FLC (fighting load carrier) with my basic load of 210 rds of 5.56 everyday! You never know when the revolution is going to kick off!
PREACH it brother!

Hint.............(grin)
Originally Posted by gunner500


Weight should never be a concern with staying alive, there isn't a swinging dick on here that hasn't begged, connived, pleaded, hoodwinked his way into gladly hoisting a 120lb woman up in the shower and hammering himself stupid! and will every damn chance he gets.

Carrying extra ammo could be the difference in getting to do that again, not to mention being alive to watch out for that woman and kids for the remainder of your life....



Jerry, I never thought of it that way, but that's a right smart way of putting it.

Anyways, I always carry at least one spare mag/speedstrip for any single-stack or revolver. A Glock can usually stay fed on what's in the magazine, or to fight my way back to the other magazines I have stashed in the truck/backpack.
Originally Posted by FieldGrade
I'd never admit to carrying a "manbag" on this site......never.


..you're behind the times...what do you think all those "sling bags" are that are in the "Tacticool" magazines... I've been carrying this little black pouch since the 1990s. It's also a nice place to stash my backup gun...
Originally Posted by deflave
Originally Posted by chlinstructor
Originally Posted by Yondering
I carry a spare mag, mainly because mag-related malfunctions are the most likely thing to cause a problem. I understand why some prefer to carry more than 1 spare although I don't myself. I don't see any good reason not to carry at least one; stuff happens we can't predict, and having a spare is no hindrance to my everyday life.
Good point.
No.

It really ain’t a good point.

Who the fugk is walking around with a mag that induces malfunctions in their carry weapon? How often does this occur?

Good point.
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by deflave
Originally Posted by chlinstructor
Originally Posted by Yondering
I carry a spare mag, mainly because mag-related malfunctions are the most likely thing to cause a problem. I understand why some prefer to carry more than 1 spare although I don't myself. I don't see any good reason not to carry at least one; stuff happens we can't predict, and having a spare is no hindrance to my everyday life.
Good point.
No.

It really ain’t a good point.

Who the fugk is walking around with a mag that induces malfunctions in their carry weapon? How often does this occur?

Good point.


And that's why I strapped with Glock Perfection!......Get Some!!!
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine

And that's why I strapped with Glock Perfection!......Get Some!!!

Only way to go.
Originally Posted by Big Stick


[Linked Image]



You can fugkin' keep that lever on the bottom operating fugkin' schit.
Here's what my nephew packs along on duty (8PM to 6AM shift in the Phoenix ghetto).

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

PS I went on a ride along for his entire shift a couple of weeks ago. Crazy stuff.

"New York reload" always made more sense to me.
Originally Posted by night_owl
"New York reload" always made more sense to me.

An Airweight J-Frame?
Originally Posted by JGray
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
I don't generally carry a spare mag for the Glock 17.

Lot's of good reasons to do so...………..but I like living on the edge.....grin

I've met you - bad asses don't need no spare mags grin


I'm really a pretty easy going person. I generally keep a poker face in public. People tend to take a friendly face for foolishness, an easy hustle, etc.
Yes, or something like an LCP - something light weight.
I carry one spare magazine, except when I am going down to the border, then I carry two--and I have an AR in the vehicle.

For ten years, I lived and worked on a ranch that had 25 miles of the international boundary as its southern border. I always had a 1911 or a Browning .40 on my belt, with two spare magazines on the other side. Never had to draw a gun on illegals, whether they were just walking or actually carrying contraband.

Nowadays, it's a different world.
'flave,

Yes one can...to the chagrin of thangs in front of the muzzle.

Hint............(grin)
just the P365 and the 13 it holds
just the P365 and the 13 it holds
Spare mag, hell, I carry a spare gun.
Originally Posted by chlinstructor
Originally Posted by local_dirt
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
I wear these suspenders every day. They are strong, and do not get in the way of where I put my holster (strongside or stong side behind hip bone). They keep everything riding where it should be.

https://www.duluthtrading.com/mens-contractor-suspenders-91236.html




No Jethro jokes from your local co-constuents? laugh


Naah, Jethro used a rope to keep his pants up!



Haha. Yeah, that's right. laugh
Originally Posted by jimmyp
just the P365 and the 13 it holds



Didn't know it had that capacity.

Put my grubby mitts on one last weekend.
Originally Posted by mudhen
I carry one spare magazine, except when I am going down to the border, then I carry two--and I have an AR in the vehicle.

For ten years, I lived and worked on a ranch that had 25 miles of the international boundary as its southern border. I always had a 1911 or a Browning .40 on my belt, with two spare magazines on the other side. Never had to draw a gun on illegals, whether they were just walking or actually carrying contraband.

Nowadays, it's a different world.



Geez.
Originally Posted by local_dirt
Originally Posted by jimmyp
just the P365 and the 13 it holds



Didn't know it had that capacity.

Put my grubby mitts on one last weekend.


12 round mags available
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
If I was down by the southern border, I'd be rolling heavy too. Here in MT, it's a little different.




I'd do the same. Same reason I go heavy when I have to go into the bowels areas of Miami.
I am a full-time judge in our state's district court. My decisions often upset folks. They don't like being put in jail, and they don't like their kinfolk being put in jail.

I walk through same parking lot each day at 5:00 PM. My most likely unwanted scenario is a bad guy, lying in wait, who is pissed and is going to even the score with me. I will likely be on my own for a couple minutes until law enforcement arrives to assist. I have no idea how many rounds I'm statistically likely going to need, so I carry a G19 and a spare magazine. I can't disagree that I probably won't ever need the spare magazine, but I feel better having it along.

On weekends, I often don't care the spare. On my "cheat days" I carry a Kahr PM9 (7+1) plus a spare 6 round mag.
Originally Posted by RJM
Originally Posted by FieldGrade
I'd never admit to carrying a "manbag" on this site......never.


..you're behind the times...what do you think all those "sling bags" are that are in the "Tacticool" magazines... I've been carrying this little black pouch since the 1990s. It's also a nice place to stash my backup gun...


Make sure it's big enough.

Anything too small for a laptop says "shoot me first".
Originally Posted by Waders
I am a full-time judge in our state's district court. My decisions often upset folks. They don't like being put in jail, and they don't like their kinfolk being put in jail.

I walk through same parking lot each day at 5:00 PM. My most likely unwanted scenario is a bad guy, lying in wait, who is pissed and is going to even the score with me. I will likely be on my own for a couple minutes until law enforcement arrives to assist. I have no idea how many rounds I'm statistically likely going to need, so I carry a G19 and a spare magazine. I can't disagree that I probably won't ever need the spare magazine, but I feel better having it along.

On weekends, I often don't care the spare. On my "cheat days" I carry a Kahr PM9 (7+1) plus a spare 6 round mag.




Othing worse than running out of ammo when in a target enriched environment.
Sh it can go south people, the space shuttle blew up twice:

Originally Posted by jwp475
Originally Posted by Waders
I am a full-time judge in our state's district court. My decisions often upset folks. They don't like being put in jail, and they don't like their kinfolk being put in jail.

I walk through same parking lot each day at 5:00 PM. My most likely unwanted scenario is a bad guy, lying in wait, who is pissed and is going to even the score with me. I will likely be on my own for a couple minutes until law enforcement arrives to assist. I have no idea how many rounds I'm statistically likely going to need, so I carry a G19 and a spare magazine. I can't disagree that I probably won't ever need the spare magazine, but I feel better having it along.

On weekends, I often don't care the spare. On my "cheat days" I carry a Kahr PM9 (7+1) plus a spare 6 round mag.




Nothing worse than running out of ammo when in a target enriched environment.



Amen, now that’s the mindset...
Honey,

Do NOT confuse a mag capacity "issue",with gross inability. Congratulations?!?

Hint...........
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Here's what my nephew packs along on duty (8PM to 6AM shift in the Phoenix ghetto).

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

PS I went on a ride along for his entire shift a couple of weeks ago. Crazy stuff.



Yeah pretty sure what you wrote earlier, if true would of got your nephew in a whole lot of trouble.. I did enjoy the part about his partner tossing you the 870 saying use if needed..
No. My well used G19 with 16rds is plenty.
Originally Posted by 79S
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Here's what my nephew packs along on duty (8PM to 6AM shift in the Phoenix ghetto).

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

PS I went on a ride along for his entire shift a couple of weeks ago. Crazy stuff.



Yeah pretty sure what you wrote earlier, if true would of got your nephew in a whole lot of trouble.. I did enjoy the part about his partner tossing you the 870 saying use if needed..

I have no idea what you're speaking of, LOL.
Originally Posted by 79S
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Here's what my nephew packs along on duty (8PM to 6AM shift in the Phoenix ghetto).

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

PS I went on a ride along for his entire shift a couple of weeks ago. Crazy stuff.



Yeah pretty sure what you wrote earlier, if true would of got your nephew in a whole lot of trouble.. I did enjoy the part about his partner tossing you the 870 saying use if needed..


Locally, that would of gotten the Nephew fired. I have no idea how different things are in Phoenix.
On duty we're required to carry three.

Off duty I usually don't carry a back up if I'm carrying my G17.

If I'm carrying something with a smaller capacity then I do.

-Jake
Originally Posted by Big Stick
'flave,

Yes one can...to the chagrin of thangs in front of the muzzle.

Hint............(grin)


I admit to owning one myself.

But don't tell nobody.
I carry a pocket gun so, yes I carry a spare mag, but that is not as many rounds as some carry in the mag in their gun.
There is that old sayin, . . . . "Ain't gonna die for lack of shootin!!!"
Mine only holds 6+1. 18.5" bbl. Runs smooth.

[Linked Image]
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Mine only holds 6+1. 18.5" bbl. Runs smooth.

[Linked Image]

.45-70? Nice elephant gun.
Yes, 45-70. I don't load it to redline though.
The downside of carrying and extra mag and not needing it is about zero.

The downside of not having one and needing it is high.

It’s all about risk management and risk avoidance.

Can’t imagine any gunfight where too much available ammo is bad.
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Yes, 45-70. I don't load it to redline though.

I've got the Winchester 1886 short rifle in .45-70 (Made by Miroku, in Japan). Front sight is too low. With the rear sight all the way down, it still hits like six inches high at 100 yards. I guess the solution is going to be to install a taller front sight.

Of Course I can only use standard pressure .45-70, unlike your Marlin.
In defending my reason for carrying 2 extra magazines is that ....with all 3 mags, I only have a total of 19 rounds. Dumping a magazine and doing a reload, helps keep track of “exactly” how much ammo I have left! memtb
Originally Posted by memtb
In defending my reason for carrying 2 extra magazines is that ....with all 3 mags, I only have a total of 19 rounds. Dumping a magazine and doing a reload, helps keep track of “exactly” how much ammo I have left! memtb

When your mag only holds 6, it makes perfect sense to carry an extra mag or two.
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Mine only holds 6+1. 18.5" bbl. Runs smooth.

[Linked Image]

.45-70? Nice elephant gun.




I've got one. I'm sure it works on 2-legged elephants, too.
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Yes, 45-70. I don't load it to redline though.

I've got the Winchester 1886 short rifle in .45-70 (Made by Miroku, in Japan). Front sight is too low. With the rear sight all the way down, it still hits like six inches high at 100 yards. I guess the solution is going to be to install a taller front sight.

Of Course I can only use standard pressure .45-70, unlike your Marlin.


I thought the modern 1886 was reputed to be stronger than the modern Marlin 1895?


Buffalo Bore gives it the green light for their "45-70 Magnum" loads:

"…...all Winchester 1886 iterations made since 1915....."

https://www.buffalobore.com/index.php?l=product_detail&p=154
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by 79S
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Here's what my nephew packs along on duty (8PM to 6AM shift in the Phoenix ghetto).

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

PS I went on a ride along for his entire shift a couple of weeks ago. Crazy stuff.



Yeah pretty sure what you wrote earlier, if true would of got your nephew in a whole lot of trouble.. I did enjoy the part about his partner tossing you the 870 saying use if needed..

I have no idea what you're speaking of, LOL.


What would of made this even more believable was when your nephew partner went to hand you the shotgun. You replied no need for that and you showed him a pair of nickel plated 1911 with ivory grips chambered in 38 supers. Every time they responded to an incident you yell let's go deliver some justice!
Originally Posted by memtb
In defending my reason for carrying 2 extra magazines is that ....with all 3 mags, I only have a total of 19 rounds. Dumping a magazine and doing a reload, helps keep track of “exactly” how much ammo I have left! memtb


This is sound tactics.

I'm not sure where "they" get "their" statics, but I trust Clint Smith's data more, and fully believe a person is predisposed to empty the mag just because the threat will still be standing even when hit.

My training is to shoot until the threat (or threats) drops from my sight picture, cover while making a tactical reload. Sweep the area for additional threats.

Not having the back up mag makes a tactical reload problematic.

Also, as memtb states, after the reload, I know I have one in the pipe and a full mag, in case of additional surprises.
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Yes, 45-70. I don't load it to redline though.


No need. I shot a bull elk with a .45-70. I think the MV of the 400gr bullet was something like 1650. The bullet went through his spine and the offside shoulder blade. It was kind of cool.

Yours is a beautiful gun! Especially the bluing. The checkering on the plywood stock looks nice too!
Originally Posted by 79S
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by 79S
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Here's what my nephew packs along on duty (8PM to 6AM shift in the Phoenix ghetto).

[Linked Image]

[Linked Image]

PS I went on a ride along for his entire shift a couple of weeks ago. Crazy stuff.



Yeah pretty sure what you wrote earlier, if true would of got your nephew in a whole lot of trouble.. I did enjoy the part about his partner tossing you the 870 saying use if needed..

I have no idea what you're speaking of, LOL.


What would of made this even more believable was when your nephew partner went to hand you the shotgun. You replied no need for that and you showed him a pair of nickel plated 1911 with ivory grips chambered in 38 supers. Every time they responded to an incident you yell let's go deliver some justice!


🤣😂😎
My light load is a 405gr cast over 15gr Unique, for 1250 fps.

My heavier load is really a mid-range load, 405gr JFP over 40gr RL-7, for 1500 fps.




The commercial heavy 405 gr loads seem to be up around 2000 fps....wpw!
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Yes, 45-70. I don't load it to redline though.

I've got the Winchester 1886 short rifle in .45-70 (Made by Miroku, in Japan). Front sight is too low. With the rear sight all the way down, it still hits like six inches high at 100 yards. I guess the solution is going to be to install a taller front sight.

Of Course I can only use standard pressure .45-70, unlike your Marlin.


I thought the modern 1886 was reputed to be stronger than the modern Marlin 1895?


Buffalo Bore gives it the green light for their "45-70 Magnum" loads:

"…...all Winchester 1886 iterations made since 1915....."

https://www.buffalobore.com/index.php?l=product_detail&p=154

You're correct Shane - the Browning/Winchester (Miroku) 1886's can be loaded to the same levels as the Marlin. I've loaded quite a bit for both and don't redline them either. About 1600 fps with a 405 cast is about as heavy as I go, and usually less at around 1300-1400 with IMR 3031. I think they list three levels of loads for 45-70: Trapdoor (blackpowder velocities), 1886/Marlin and then Ruger No. 1 at the top end.
Originally Posted by gunner500
Weight should never be a concern with staying alive, there isn't a swinging dick on here that hasn't begged, connived, pleaded, hoodwinked his way into gladly hoisting a 120lb woman up in the shower and hammering himself stupid! and will every damn chance he gets.



How has this argument not made it into a ultralight hunting rifle thread.
Originally Posted by Big Stick
The only time I've ever thought that I might come in 2nd Place,was on Chichagof. Had (5) Brownies in proximity,the furthest being 20yds away. (2) Boars to my left and a Sow and Twins to my right,post Rut(luckily).

I KNEW someone would find the Satin Nickle BHP in my mitts emptied,but really didn't know what the Final Score was gonna read.(grin)

An extry mag(which I had on me at the time),wasn't gonna "help" and I luckily managed to slip away,less pressing the trigger.

Woulda made a nice video.

Hint....................(grin)



Still not sure if “Chichagof” is Stickaneese for Chicago.
Rarely, of course I almost always carried a glock.
Originally Posted by rgrx1276
No. My well used G19 with 16rds is plenty.



You know this how?
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Yes, 45-70. I don't load it to redline though.

I've got the Winchester 1886 short rifle in .45-70 (Made by Miroku, in Japan). Front sight is too low. With the rear sight all the way down, it still hits like six inches high at 100 yards. I guess the solution is going to be to install a taller front sight.

Of Course I can only use standard pressure .45-70, unlike your Marlin.


I thought the modern 1886 was reputed to be stronger than the modern Marlin 1895?


Buffalo Bore gives it the green light for their "45-70 Magnum" loads:

"…...all Winchester 1886 iterations made since 1915....."

https://www.buffalobore.com/index.php?l=product_detail&p=154
That's cool to know. Thanks.
Originally Posted by 79S

What would of made this even more believable was when your nephew partner went to hand you the shotgun. You replied no need for that and you showed him a pair of nickel plated 1911 with ivory grips chambered in 38 supers. Every time they responded to an incident you yell let's go deliver some justice!

You must have been there. How else would you know about the the nickel plated 1911s with ivory grips in .38 Super incident?
Not usually. I carry 2 different handguns regularly depending on what I am wearing. J frame 38 snubbie in right front pocket or a M&P 9 shield in either an IWB or OWB holster depending on once again what I am wearing.
I tend to keep things simple across the board. I tend to carry the same gun in my town, in the woods, on vacation, in big cities, at IDPA matches, etc. It usually is a compact, and I carry two spares. Everything balances out nicely, and the total weight is within a couple ounces of something like a loaded Glock 17 or Glock 19, but the total round count is double the 19.
Interesting thread. Carrying a 9mil 12+1 and one spare magazine, loose in a pocket. Mag carrier is not comfortable to carry. I would like a couple of spare mags for truck and car, but currently only have the two.
Ohio requires retreat if possible, except in defense of your life or another's life. We lost "stand your ground" at the polls a few years ago.
Originally Posted by deflave
I don't carry any spare mags.

Same here... Once in a great while, depending on location at the time... But rarely..
Originally Posted by kellory
Interesting thread. Carrying a 9mil 12+1 and one spare magazine, loose in a pocket. Mag carrier is not comfortable to carry. I would like a couple of spare mags for truck and car, but currently only have the two.
Ohio requires retreat if possible, except in defense of your life or another's life. We lost "stand your ground" at the polls a few years ago.

That sucks.
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Originally Posted by The_Real_Hawkeye
Originally Posted by MontanaMarine
Yes, 45-70. I don't load it to redline though.

I've got the Winchester 1886 short rifle in .45-70 (Made by Miroku, in Japan). Front sight is too low. With the rear sight all the way down, it still hits like six inches high at 100 yards. I guess the solution is going to be to install a taller front sight.

Of Course I can only use standard pressure .45-70, unlike your Marlin.


I thought the modern 1886 was reputed to be stronger than the modern Marlin 1895?


Buffalo Bore gives it the green light for their "45-70 Magnum" loads:

"…...all Winchester 1886 iterations made since 1915....."

https://www.buffalobore.com/index.php?l=product_detail&p=154
Just realized that I misidentified the Model I have. I actually have the Model 1886 Extra Light Rifle with a 22” barrel, short 4-shot magazine, and a straight butt plate, not the Short Rifle variant.
Originally Posted by kellory
Interesting thread. Carrying a 9mil 12+1 and one spare magazine, loose in a pocket. Mag carrier is not comfortable to carry. I would like a couple of spare mags for truck and car, but currently only have the two.
Ohio requires retreat if possible, except in defense of your life or another's life. We lost "stand your ground" at the polls a few years ago.




kellory, what's with Ohio? I thought Ohio was a good ole boy state.
Carrying additional magazines depends on whether I believe I might need or want more ammo. Absolute arguments are pointless.
I just depends on what I am doing, and the type of clothing that I am wearing. For the most part, if I am just out and about, I only care the concealed firearm with 13 rnds in it.
If I know that I'm going to be near a den of iniquity, then I usually have at least one extra magazine with 12 rounds in it. Sometimes two.

Originally Posted by local_dirt

Ohio requires retreat if possible, except in defense of your life or another's life. We lost "stand your ground" at the polls a few years ago.




Unless another life is at risk, why put yourself in harms way ? Seek cover and concealment until LEO's arrive.

You never know how amped up the "active shooter" is on meth or how well armed they are compared to you.


.
If I don't carry a spare mag for my G 19, I carry a baton on my left side (right handed) to balance out my pistol.

Makes my load balance better, so my pants don't sag as much on the right side.

Virgil B.
Originally Posted by Owl


Unless another life is at risk, why put yourself in harms way ? Seek cover and concealment until LEO's arrive.

You never know how amped up the "active shooter" is on meth or how well armed they are compared to you.


.


A far bigger concern than meth or any other drug is the fact that once somebody starts shooting, the cops are on their way and looking for a person with a gun.

If somebody can save the day, by all means. But I wouldn't go full Mogadishu unless I'm in uniform.
Originally Posted by kingston
Originally Posted by Big Stick
The only time I've ever thought that I might come in 2nd Place,was on Chichagof. Had (5) Brownies in proximity,the furthest being 20yds away. (2) Boars to my left and a Sow and Twins to my right,post Rut(luckily).

I KNEW someone would find the Satin Nickle BHP in my mitts emptied,but really didn't know what the Final Score was gonna read.(grin)

An extry mag(which I had on me at the time),wasn't gonna "help" and I luckily managed to slip away,less pressing the trigger.

Woulda made a nice video.

Hint....................(grin)



Still not sure if “Chichagof” is Stickaneese for Chicago.


It's an island in pws know for brown bears and lots of them.. it's part of the ABC island chain. Admiralty, Baranof, Chichagof

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chichagof_Island
Originally Posted by deflave
Originally Posted by Owl


Unless another life is at risk, why put yourself in harms way ? Seek cover and concealment until LEO's arrive.

You never know how amped up the "active shooter" is on meth or how well armed they are compared to you.


.


A far bigger concern than meth or any other drug is the fact that once somebody starts shooting, the cops are on their way and looking for a person with a gun.

If somebody can save the day, by all means. But I wouldn't go full Mogadishu unless I'm in uniform.


So don't strip down to my khaki pants cut off at the knees and flip flops ???
Originally Posted by Owl
I just depends on what I am doing, and the type of clothing that I am wearing. For the most part, if I am just out and about, I only care the concealed firearm with 13 rnds in it.
If I know that I'm going to be near a den of iniquity, then I usually have at least one extra magazine with 12 rounds in it. Sometimes two.

Originally Posted by local_dirt

Ohio requires retreat if possible, except in defense of your life or another's life. We lost "stand your ground" at the polls a few years ago.




Unless another life is at risk, why put yourself in harms way ? Seek cover and concealment until LEO's arrive.

You never know how amped up the "active shooter" is on meth or how well armed they are compared to you.


.

You have this misquoted. These are my words. However, it is not my job or responsibility to put myself in harm's way, only to stop an attack upon myself, or another with an eye to retreat. Only in my home, is it assumed that retreat is impossible or impractical.
I'll probably carry more when I get older and wear jeans/shirt/vest in August.

About 8 months of the year I'm in shorts and a tee or button down. It's hell carrying 3 spare mags with swim trunks.
Interesting thread w/ many opinions.

Having gone dry or close to it on several occasions I prefer to carry an extra mag for my G19. My pants stay up and it is easier to conceal than a second gun. I know that I cannot predict the circumstances of a fight and fleeing may not be the best option. Should a malfunction occur I will correct it if possible not analyze the cause. If TRB fails the next option includes a reload which I prefer to do using a new, full mag. When the immediate problem is solved I will scan the area prior to reloading if not at slidelock, I have never been good at counting the rounds fired. I think tactical reloads are a range thing, have fresh mag positioned properly in hand, eject current mag and let fall and quickly but positively replace w/ new mag. Less chance of fumbling, if circumstances permit pick up partially used mag and stow.

As soon as you are positive that your environment is safe return your gun to concealed and seek better cover.

YMMV


mike r
FYI Joe Schit the Ragman is my cousin
I carry my extra mag for the Glock 43 in my change pocket on my right (strong) side. Not ideal, but that’s why I’m having a friend’s wife sew change pockets on the left side, too.
https://www.blueforcegear.com/single-pistol-belt-pouch.html

Take off the velcro belt loop and it has a sewn in sleeve that lets you run your belt through it and carry any pistol magazine, double or single stack, horizontally and concealed with a T-shirt. Most useful mag carrier I've tried.
Yes
Originally Posted by TWR
https://www.blueforcegear.com/single-pistol-belt-pouch.html

Take off the Velcro belt loop and it has a sewn in sleeve that lets you run your belt through it and carry any pistol magazine, double or single stack, horizontally and concealed with a T-shirt. Most useful mag carrier I've tried.


Didn't see the sewn in sleeve that allows you to carry base plate oriented up?

I may get one for T&E.
Horizontally as in parallel with your belt. The velcro is in the sleeve. look at the 5th pic in the link.
Originally Posted by cs2blue
2 is one and one is none! always carry a reload, always! Cuz you just never know!


That's right cs2blue, anyone with at least two unpickled or dope addled functioning brain cells would know this. smile
Originally Posted by DocRocket
Originally Posted by gunner500


Weight should never be a concern with staying alive, there isn't a swinging dick on here that hasn't begged, connived, pleaded, hoodwinked his way into gladly hoisting a 120lb woman up in the shower and hammering himself stupid! and will every damn chance he gets.

Carrying extra ammo could be the difference in getting to do that again, not to mention being alive to watch out for that woman and kids for the remainder of your life....



Jerry, I never thought of it that way, but that's a right smart way of putting it.

Anyways, I always carry at least one spare mag/speedstrip for any single-stack or revolver. A Glock can usually stay fed on what's in the magazine, or to fight my way back to the other magazines I have stashed in the truck/backpack.


Yessir Doc, we as men have created a lot of responsibility, husbands, dads, buddies, possible caretakers for our aging parents, business owners [ie employees], a lot of people depend on use being there, so whether to a booked chitstorm or going to the damn post office, we need to get there and back. smile I don't know or care what another man carries, but hope they all do.
Originally Posted by kingston
Originally Posted by gunner500
Weight should never be a concern with staying alive, there isn't a swinging dick on here that hasn't begged, connived, pleaded, hoodwinked his way into gladly hoisting a 120lb woman up in the shower and hammering himself stupid! and will every damn chance he gets.



How has this argument not made it into a ultralight hunting rifle thread.


It has, after I read someone exclaim, oh, you can lose a whole half ounce going to a titanium bolt handle, I said if you'll clean your muddy boots and take a good chit you can lose a whole ten pounds, never mind happily sitting down for another slice of pie adding to the 80+lbs they've put on their asses since school. crazy

Cant put my finger on exactly when we became so vaginalized.
Originally Posted by TWR
Horizontally as in parallel with your belt. The velcro is in the sleeve. look at the 5th pic in the link.


That makes sense.
Here is Clint Smith's opinion on spare magazines and magazines in general!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mVG9D6IVpkQ

Nuff Said!!

Elk Country
Originally Posted by gunner500


Yessir Doc, we as men have created a lot of responsibility, husbands, dads, buddies, possible caretakers for our aging parents, business owners [ie employees], a lot of people depend on use being there, so whether to a booked chitstorm or going to the damn post office, we need to get there and back. smile I don't know or care what another man carries, but hope they all do.


I see you are a man who takes his responsibilities seriously. I like the way you think.
Originally Posted by TWR
https://www.blueforcegear.com/single-pistol-belt-pouch.html

Take off the velcro belt loop and it has a sewn in sleeve that lets you run your belt through it and carry any pistol magazine, double or single stack, horizontally and concealed with a T-shirt. Most useful mag carrier I've tried.

Thank you, I think I'll be taking your advice.
I figure the odds of me needing a defensive weapon is slim.

Not counting time on duty I've put in about 20,000 days and needed a weapon exactly 4 times.

Total reloads needed = 0

And I'm older and smarter than before...
Originally Posted by johnw
I figure the odds of me needing a defensive weapon is slim.

Not counting time on duty I've put in about 20,000 days and needed a weapon exactly 4 times.

Total reloads needed = 0

And I'm older and smarter than before...


And so much better looking
Originally Posted by 79S
Originally Posted by kingston
Originally Posted by Big Stick
The only time I've ever thought that I might come in 2nd Place,was on Chichagof. Had (5) Brownies in proximity,the furthest being 20yds away. (2) Boars to my left and a Sow and Twins to my right,post Rut(luckily).

I KNEW someone would find the Satin Nickle BHP in my mitts emptied,but really didn't know what the Final Score was gonna read.(grin)

An extry mag(which I had on me at the time),wasn't gonna "help" and I luckily managed to slip away,less pressing the trigger.

Woulda made a nice video.

Hint....................(grin)



Still not sure if “Chichagof” is Stickaneese for Chicago.


It's an island in pws know for brown bears and lots of them.. it's part of the ABC island chain. Admiralty, Baranof, Chichagof

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chichagof_Island


That makes sense too.
Originally Posted by kellory
Originally Posted by TWR
https://www.blueforcegear.com/single-pistol-belt-pouch.html

Take off the velcro belt loop and it has a sewn in sleeve that lets you run your belt through it and carry any pistol magazine, double or single stack, horizontally and concealed with a T-shirt. Most useful mag carrier I've tried.

Thank you, I think I'll be taking your advice.


You're welcome. One bit of advice, I carry the mag kinda like a left side appendix carry and keep the base plate towards my buckle. With the buckle going towards the outside, the mag can work it's way out.

Once you get one in your hands, it'll become clear.
Originally Posted by Yondering
Originally Posted by gunner500


Yessir Doc, we as men have created a lot of responsibility, husbands, dads, buddies, possible caretakers for our aging parents, business owners [ie employees], a lot of people depend on use being there, so whether to a booked chitstorm or going to the damn post office, we need to get there and back. smile I don't know or care what another man carries, but hope they all do.


I see you are a man who takes his responsibilities seriously. I like the way you think.


Thanks. smile
depending on what handgun I'm carrying, I carry extra ammo. With the 642 Smith revolver, two speed strips. With the XDS, one or two extra magazines. With the Glock 19, just one extra.
When I carried a 1911, yes. Glock, no.🤔
© 24hourcampfire