Home
Posted By: TreeMutt Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/06/21
I just conjured up a load for my Ruger 77ST, 30-06, old tang safety model, mounting a fairly new Weaver Classic K6X38 scope that I don't think I'm going to tinker with anymore (yeah right smile

It's no screamer but it's really accurate. 48.5 grains of IMR4064 behind a Sierra 165 HPBT Game King in a Federal case, CCI 200 primer, OAL 3.200. I'll get around to measuring it's speed soon.

Several 3 shot groups into nearly one hole or maybe I better call it 1/4" capable if I really do my part. This is unusually very good for me and this rifle.

My question is; the zero for this load is about 1/8" inch from the center of the aiming point at 100 yards. Any idea where this bullet will impact center because of spin drift, if it ever will? ......Thanks, JJ
Shoot multiple 10 shot groups. That will give you a better idea of where the center of your group is. 3 shot groups really tell you nothing. I was at the range yesterday testing some loads with my new to me rifle and some of the groups showed double grouping where the first 3 shots were in one ragged hole, then the next 2 were outside the group by 1/2"+. Getting all fancy and talking about spin drift and bragging about 1/4" groups, "if you do your part" really is a moot point, if you are not shooting more per string. Here's an interesting read for you:

The trouble with 3 shot groups
Posted By: dan_oz Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/06/21
Originally Posted by TreeMutt


My question is; the zero for this load is about 1/8" inch from the center of the aiming point at 100 yards. Any idea where this bullet will impact center because of spin drift, if it ever will? ......Thanks, JJ


The effect of spin drift is fairly small until you get a long way out there - less than 1/2 moa at 500 yards in all likelihood, maybe 1 moa at 1000 - easily lost in the effects of other things like atmospherics. There are formulas and calculators. Personally I've never worried about it for a hunting rifle, and even in 1000 yard competition it is a simple matter of recording your sight settings in a notebook (and of course adjusting for the conditions).
Originally Posted by TreeMutt
I just conjured up a load for my Ruger 77ST, 30-06, old tang safety model, mounting a fairly new Weaver Classic K6X38 scope that I don't think I'm going to tinker with anymore (yeah right smile

It's no screamer but it's really accurate. 48.5 grains of IMR4064 behind a Sierra 165 HPBT Game King in a Federal case, CCI 200 primer, OAL 3.200. I'll get around to measuring it's speed soon.

Several 3 shot groups into nearly one hole or maybe I better call it 1/4" capable if I really do my part. This is unusually very good for me and this rifle.

My question is; the zero for this load is about 1/8" inch from the center of the aiming point at 100 yards. Any idea where this bullet will impact center because of spin drift, if it ever will? ......Thanks, JJ


Your zero is 1/8” from POA in which direction? What ROT is the barrel? Assuming RH twist barrels, I often favour the left of POA when I zero at 100 meters just to offset spin drift farther downrange. Fast-twist barrels induce more spin drift than barrels with a slower twist rate. In your case, assuming a 11” twist rate, 2975 fps at the muzzle, SAC, and a 100 m zero, spin drift causes 2” of deflection at 500 m and 15” at 1000 m. In angular units this is about 0.1 MRAD/0.3 MOA and 0.4 MRAD/1.3 MOA, respectively. If instead of zeroing right on at 100 m you zero 0.3” left of POA, spin drift will be reduced to 0.5” at 500 m and 12” at 1000 m, or 0 MRAD/0.1 MOA and 0.3 MRAD/1 MOA, respectively.
Posted By: TreeMutt Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/06/21
J O'Connor said, in his opinion, the accuracy of a hunting rifle should be judged by a 3 shot group....
Originally Posted by Jordan Smith
Originally Posted by TreeMutt
I just conjured up a load for my Ruger 77ST, 30-06, old tang safety model, mounting a fairly new Weaver Classic K6X38 scope that I don't think I'm going to tinker with anymore (yeah right smile

It's no screamer but it's really accurate. 48.5 grains of IMR4064 behind a Sierra 165 HPBT Game King in a Federal case, CCI 200 primer, OAL 3.200. I'll get around to measuring it's speed soon.

Several 3 shot groups into nearly one hole or maybe I better call it 1/4" capable if I really do my part. This is unusually very good for me and this rifle.

My question is; the zero for this load is about 1/8" inch from the center of the aiming point at 100 yards. Any idea where this bullet will impact center because of spin drift, if it ever will? ......Thanks, JJ


Your zero is 1/8” from POA in which direction? What ROT is the barrel? Assuming RH twist barrels, I often favour the left of POA when I zero at 100 meters just to offset spin drift farther downrange. Fast-twist barrels induce more spin drift than barrels with a slower twist rate. In your case, assuming a 11” twist rate, 2975 fps at the muzzle, SAC, and a 100 m zero, spin drift causes 2” of deflection at 500 m and 15” at 1000 m. In angular units this is about 0.1 MRAD/0.3 MOA and 0.4 MRAD/1.3 MOA, respectively. If instead of zeroing right on at 100 m you zero 0.3” left of POA, spin drift will be reduced to 0.5” at 500 m and 12” at 1000 m, or 0 MRAD/0.1 MOA and 0.3 MRAD/1 MOA, respectively.
Posted By: WAM Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/06/21
What say you, Mule Deer?
Posted By: CGPAUL Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/06/21
Very good explanations in the above responses.
You mentioned "several" groups produced tight groups. Consistent POI? If so, I would go with it, and test shoot at 3 and 500 yrds. Atmospherics will always be the biggest challenge, IME.
PS, that`s why sights are adjustable.
Posted By: Mule Deer Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/06/21
WAM,

I have also published articles and book chapters about the problem with making accuracy judgments on 3-shot groups. Among other things, a professional statistician I'm acquainted with calculated that the average point-of-impact from several 3-shot groups will vary around .7 inch at 100 yards, which doesn't help much when calculating downrange spin-drift.

Will also note that Elmer Keith, who did quite a bit of long-range target shooting, and what was considered long-range big game hunting back in his day, preferred to sight-in his long-range hunting rifles 3 inches high at 100 yards--and half an inch to the left, to compensate for spin-drift with a typical RH twist barrel.
Posted By: jwp475 Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/06/21

I've never experienced spin drift in my 338 Laura with the 300 grain SMK. I've spoken to Brian Lietz about this and he said there are explanation why but spin drift is still there
Posted By: navlav8r Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/06/21
Originally Posted by Mule Deer
WAM,

I have also published articles and book chapters about the problem with making accuracy judgments on 3-shot groups. Among other things, a professional statistician I'm acquainted with calculated that the average point-of-impact from several 3-shot groups will vary around .7 inch at 100 yards, which doesn't help much when calculating downrange spin-drift.

Will also note that Elmer Keith, who did quite a bit of long-range target shooting, and what was considered long-range big game hunting back in his day, preferred to sight-in his long-range hunting rifles 3 inches high at 100 yards--and half an inch to the left, to compensate for spin-drift with a typical RH twist barrel.



When I started reading this thread, Elmer Keith’s sight-in technique was the first thing that popped into my head. I can’t tell you how many times I read that in his articles 😊
Originally Posted by TreeMutt
J O'Connor said, in his opinion, the accuracy of a hunting rifle should be judged by a 3 shot group....
Originally Posted by Jordan Smith
Originally Posted by TreeMutt
I just conjured up a load for my Ruger 77ST, 30-06, old tang safety model, mounting a fairly new Weaver Classic K6X38 scope that I don't think I'm going to tinker with anymore (yeah right smile

It's no screamer but it's really accurate. 48.5 grains of IMR4064 behind a Sierra 165 HPBT Game King in a Federal case, CCI 200 primer, OAL 3.200. I'll get around to measuring it's speed soon.

Several 3 shot groups into nearly one hole or maybe I better call it 1/4" capable if I really do my part. This is unusually very good for me and this rifle.

My question is; the zero for this load is about 1/8" inch from the center of the aiming point at 100 yards. Any idea where this bullet will impact center because of spin drift, if it ever will? ......Thanks, JJ


Your zero is 1/8” from POA in which direction? What ROT is the barrel? Assuming RH twist barrels, I often favour the left of POA when I zero at 100 meters just to offset spin drift farther downrange. Fast-twist barrels induce more spin drift than barrels with a slower twist rate. In your case, assuming a 11” twist rate, 2975 fps at the muzzle, SAC, and a 100 m zero, spin drift causes 2” of deflection at 500 m and 15” at 1000 m. In angular units this is about 0.1 MRAD/0.3 MOA and 0.4 MRAD/1.3 MOA, respectively. If instead of zeroing right on at 100 m you zero 0.3” left of POA, spin drift will be reduced to 0.5” at 500 m and 12” at 1000 m, or 0 MRAD/0.1 MOA and 0.3 MRAD/1 MOA, respectively.


I think this response was directed at the wrong person...
Posted By: TreeMutt Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/06/21
Originally Posted by Jordan Smith
Originally Posted by TreeMutt
J O'Connor said, in his opinion, the accuracy of a hunting rifle should be judged by a 3 shot group....
Originally Posted by Jordan Smith
Originally Posted by TreeMutt
I just conjured up a load for my Ruger 77ST, 30-06, old tang safety model, mounting a fairly new Weaver Classic K6X38 scope that I don't think I'm going to tinker with anymore (yeah right smile

It's no screamer but it's really accurate. 48.5 grains of IMR4064 behind a Sierra 165 HPBT Game King in a Federal case, CCI 200 primer, OAL 3.200. I'll get around to measuring it's speed soon.

Several 3 shot groups into nearly one hole or maybe I better call it 1/4" capable if I really do my part. This is unusually very good for me and this rifle.

My question is; the zero for this load is about 1/8" inch from the center of the aiming point at 100 yards. Any idea where this bullet will impact center because of spin drift, if it ever will? ......Thanks, JJ


Your zero is 1/8” from POA in which direction? What ROT is the barrel? Assuming RH twist barrels, I often favour the left of POA when I zero at 100 meters just to offset spin drift farther downrange. Fast-twist barrels induce more spin drift than barrels with a slower twist rate. In your case, assuming a 11” twist rate, 2975 fps at the muzzle, SAC, and a 100 m zero, spin drift causes 2” of deflection at 500 m and 15” at 1000 m. In angular units this is about 0.1 MRAD/0.3 MOA and 0.4 MRAD/1.3 MOA, respectively. If instead of zeroing right on at 100 m you zero 0.3” left of POA, spin drift will be reduced to 0.5” at 500 m and 12” at 1000 m, or 0 MRAD/0.1 MOA and 0.3 MRAD/1 MOA, respectively.


I think this response was directed at the wrong person...


You are correct, wrong person. The rifle has a 1-10" RH Twist and POI IS 1/8" left...O'Conner was talking about one of his custom Model 70, 270s that he used in the Yukon, British Columbia, Iran, Botswana, Idaho and Scotland, and elsewhere . After claiming how it held zero, his load of 62g H4831, Nosler bullet, Western cases and ave velocity of 3,140 in a 22 inch barrel...I quote; "if I'm having a good day, let the barrel cool a bit between shots, and take pains to hold the rifle the same for each shot, it will keep five shots in an inch or slightly over. Contrary to much of what one reads, this is exceptional. With this rifle I have shot many THREE- SHOT groups (which I think should be the standard by which a big-game rifle is judged) of 3/4 inch or a bit less".
Posted By: mathman Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/06/21
Have you ever kept shooting at a particular target until the group hole in the paper stopped growing? If not then try it sometime.
Posted By: Muffin Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/06/21
Originally Posted by mathman
Have you ever kept shooting at a particular target until the group hole in the paper stopped growing? If not then try it sometime.



Yes, did that two days ago, not on purpose, but the last three or so of each group did not make the hole bigger.... also, apart from the question, has little to do with this thread.. smile thirteen shots on the left, 10 on the right.

[Linked Image from i.imgur.com]
Posted By: WAM Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/07/21
The
Originally Posted by Mule Deer
WAM,

I have also published articles and book chapters about the problem with making accuracy judgments on 3-shot groups. Among other things, a professional statistician I'm acquainted with calculated that the average point-of-impact from several 3-shot groups will vary around .7 inch at 100 yards, which doesn't help much when calculating downrange spin-drift.

Will also note that Elmer Keith, who did quite a bit of long-range target shooting, and what was considered long-range big game hunting back in his day, preferred to sight-in his long-range hunting rifles 3 inches high at 100 yards--and half an inch to the left, to compensate for spin-drift with a typical RH twist barrel.

Agreed. I have read as much of your fine works as possible but don’t recall anything on spindrift. As I am familiar with artillery and naval gunfire characteristics, I understand spindrift. I just never gave it much thought to high velocity rifle trajectory at modest ranges since I don’t like to shoot much past 300 yards at game. But since I now have a 6.5-300 Weatherby, perhaps I should visit the spindrift effect for out to 500 yards or less. Any further insight or suggestions would be most welcome! Steve
Posted By: CGPAUL Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/07/21
If you can call wind within 1 1/2 inch, every shot, at 500, you have it figured out.
Posted By: WAM Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/07/21
What does wind correction have to do with spindrift and zero?
Posted By: aalf Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/07/21

While you're fretting spin drift, don't forget about Coriolis, and which direction you're shooting...... tired
Posted By: WAM Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/07/21
^^^^[ Oh, Yeah!!!! LOL!
Posted By: Mule Deer Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/07/21
WAM,

I have mentioned spin-drift here and there in my writings, but for most hunters, spin-drift is pretty much adjusted for for when checking clicks and adjusting zero etc. at longer ranges.

If you really want to read up on it, Bryan Litz's writings are a good resource: www.appliedballisticsllc.com.
Posted By: CGPAUL Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/07/21
Cause wind has much more effect on impact than spin drift. And if your zeroed at 5 on some windless day?? you have any spin drift compensated for with the zero.
Now you still have to call the wind, when it appears...which it will.
If you watch the mirage move through a spotting scope, even at 200 yrds with a mild 5-7 mph wind, full value or other wise, you`ll forget about spin drift.

Fun and interesting to talk about, but IME, application gets lost in the wind....or is it "Gone with the Wind"?

YMMV
Posted By: pointer Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/08/21
Originally Posted by Mule Deer
WAM,

I have also published articles and book chapters about the problem with making accuracy judgments on 3-shot groups. Among other things, a professional statistician I'm acquainted with calculated that the average point-of-impact from several 3-shot groups will vary around .7 inch at 100 yards, which doesn't help much when calculating downrange spin-drift.

Will also note that Elmer Keith, who did quite a bit of long-range target shooting, and what was considered long-range big game hunting back in his day, preferred to sight-in his long-range hunting rifles 3 inches high at 100 yards--and half an inch to the left, to compensate for spin-drift with a typical RH twist barrel.
Thanks for that last nugget. DIdn't know that.
Posted By: JGRaider Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/08/21
After 49 years of big game hunting, and guiding well over 150 hunters in the past, it's my opinion that the vast majority of hunters, especially those that aspire to excel at extended ranges, don't shoot well enough to know whether it's spin drift, wind, shooter error, bad ammo, poor form, scope issues, mount issues, etc. I've killed well over 300 head of big game and didn't even spin drift existed until reading about it a year or so ago. Therefore in my world it's a big non issue.
Posted By: CGPAUL Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/08/21
Egad man, how did you ever do it?
Posted By: Boise Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/08/21
Originally Posted by JGRaider
After 49 years of big game hunting, and guiding well over 150 hunters in the past, it's my opinion that the vast majority of hunters, especially those that aspire to excel at extended ranges, don't shoot well enough to know whether it's spin drift, wind, shooter error, bad ammo, poor form, scope issues, mount issues, etc. I've killed well over 300 head of big game and didn't even spin drift existed until reading about it a year or so ago. Therefore in my world it's a big non issue.


And without a Creedmore, who thought this possible?
Posted By: jmh3 Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/08/21
Originally Posted by CGPAUL
Cause wind has much more effect on impact than spin drift. And if your zeroed at 5 on some windless day?? you have any spin drift compensated for with the zero.
Now you still have to call the wind, when it appears...which it will.
If you watch the mirage move through a spotting scope, even at 200 yrds with a mild 5-7 mph wind, full value or other wise, you`ll forget about spin drift.

Fun and interesting to talk about, but IME, application gets lost in the wind....or is it "Gone with the Wind"?

YMMV


This^^^^^

Here are results from the ballistics program for my 6 Creed at 500 yards. Spin drift is 1.13 inches at 500 yds. Adding only a 1 mph crosswind completely offsets the spin drift. I spend quite a bit of time shooting at long range steel and I can say with certainty I can’t read a 1 mph wind in hunting conditions.

[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]

[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
Originally Posted by jmh3
Originally Posted by CGPAUL
Cause wind has much more effect on impact than spin drift. And if your zeroed at 5 on some windless day?? you have any spin drift compensated for with the zero.
Now you still have to call the wind, when it appears...which it will.
If you watch the mirage move through a spotting scope, even at 200 yrds with a mild 5-7 mph wind, full value or other wise, you`ll forget about spin drift.

Fun and interesting to talk about, but IME, application gets lost in the wind....or is it "Gone with the Wind"?

YMMV


This^^^^^

Here are results from the ballistics program for my 6 Creed at 500 yards. Spin drift is 1.13 inches at 500 yds. Adding only a 1 mph crosswind completely offsets the spin drift. I spend quite a bit of time shooting at long range steel and I can say with certainty I can’t read a 1 mph wind in hunting conditions.

[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]

[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]



The choice of bullet matters. Spin drift is a relatively small effect, but the ratio of spin drift vs. wind drift gets higher when the BC of your bullet increases, possibly to the point of no longer being lost in the noise.
Posted By: JGRaider Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/08/21
SWAG'ing it I guess !
Posted By: CGPAUL Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/09/21
That`s interesting. Any numbers suggesting when that could happen?
Posted By: CGPAUL Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/09/21
Welcome to the "Fire" White Feather!
Originally Posted by CGPAUL
That`s interesting. Any numbers suggesting when that could happen?

It's really only likely in the case of very little wind. Spin drift is proportional to SG and also to TOF^1.83, and wind drift is proportional to (TOF - TOF_vacuum), so in the case where bullet BC, bullet length, and muzzle velocity maximize SG and TOF, while minimizing (TOF - TOF_vacuum), spin drift becomes most significant compared to wind drift.

As an example of when spin drift can matter, consider the 120 gr 7mm VM leaving the barrel at 2975 fps. In SAC, an 8" RH twist results in 20.4" of spin drift at 1000 meters. Each 1 mph of wind is responsible for 16.3" of wind drift, so with a 9 o'clock 1 mph wind the total drift is 36.7" to the right. But if instead you have a 3 o'clock 1 mph wind, your total drift is 4.2". So if you were to mistakenly assume a 0 mph wind, and if you don't account for spin drift, you could be off by nearly 3 feet of drift to the right. It's an issue similar to tolerance stacking, where if unaccounted for the small errors can stack up to create a large error.
Posted By: Swifty52 Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/09/21
Well dang, might as well throw in Coriolis effect while your at it.
Posted By: Ranger99 Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/09/21
JMHO-
I make my judgment for my own hunting rifles
with 1 shot from a cold barrel. That's the only
one that counts for my purposes.
Posted By: CGPAUL Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/10/21
Well, you got me thinking. Shooting the 308 in HP at 600 and Palma matches,8,9, and 1k, wind was always a factor at the rifle ranges where I shot. Watching the flags helped, and when I got my zero, I tried to shoot the same conditions, not always possible in the alloted time frame. Knew of SD, but never really corrected for it.
But, a few weeks ago I took the 7 Rem Mag to a local power line, I can get almost 1900 yrds out of it, for something to do. Had 180 grn. Hybrid Target bullets at 3020 loaded. Set a milk jug at 1k. Conditions were damned near perfect, overcast, very lite wind that looked and felt like it was at 12 O`clock. Ran in my elevation, no wind correction. First shot was just high, but right..with this rifle I can spot my impacts at that distance..corrected with the reticule, 2nd was just left, third was a hit. I`d thought I`d missed wind call my 1st shot, thinking about it now, I believe I missed SD.
Thanks for the explanation.
Posted By: Swifty52 Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/10/21
Originally Posted by CGPAUL
Well, you got me thinking. Shooting the 308 in HP at 600 and Palma matches,8,9, and 1k, wind was always a factor at the rifle ranges where I shot. Watching the flags helped, and when I got my zero, I tried to shoot the same conditions, not always possible in the alloted time frame. Knew of SD, but never really corrected for it.
But, a few weeks ago I took the 7 Rem Mag to a local power line, I can get almost 1900 yrds out of it, for something to do. Had 180 grn. Hybrid Target bullets at 3020 loaded. Set a milk jug at 1k. Conditions were damned near perfect, overcast, very lite wind that looked and felt like it was at 12 O`clock. Ran in my elevation, no wind correction. First shot was just high, but right..with this rifle I can spot my impacts at that distance..corrected with the reticule, 2nd was just left, third was a hit. I`d thought I`d missed wind call my 1st shot, thinking about it now, I believe I missed SD.
Thanks for the explanation.


You sure? I mentioned above to bring up Coriolis Effect. Good read if you care to.

Long Range Shooting: External Ballistics – The Coriolis Effect
Posted By: CGPAUL Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/11/21
There have been so few times I`ve shot in near perfect conditions, that I plum forgot about SD, not to mention Coriolis, and still concentrate on breaking a good shot. Which is another variable in the mix.
Posted By: DBoston Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/11/21
Boxers or briefs? Spin or wind? Shoot to the left in the southern hemisphere.
Posted By: ERK Re: Spin Drift and a Zero? - 02/11/21
WOW! What a non subject. Edk
© 24hourcampfire