I'm very surprised someone hasn't come knocking looking for that deer, sounds fishy. I gave up bow hunting, I don't like having to trail up anything. Neck, high shoulder DRT.
My best guess is that the White Trash neighbors, to whom game laws and ethics mean nothing, were the culprits. In the past they have always contacted me and asked permission to track deer that they wounded........and apparently they wound as many as they kill. I figure this deer was probably on my side of the fence when they shot it, and they were too chickenchit to follow up and recover it.
I have nothing against bow hunting, and once did a lot of it myself, and killed several with a bow. But, bow hunters wound a lot of deer that are never recovered. That's one of the problems with hunting small properties of only a few acres, as you're dependent upon neighboring landowners to give you access to their land so you can track and hopefully recover a wounded deer. I hunt my 300 acre farm, and I never place a stand close to property line, as I want to lessen the chances of a deer I shoot ending up on the neighbor. I can't say the same about some of those neighbors, as they like to hunt as close to the property line as they can. It's gotten to the point where I refuse to let them look for a deer, and I'll do the looking myself.