What's the difference in weight ratings between the original and the replacement if any? IMHO, the replacement bolted down isn't as good as the welded original, but dependent on what your load I'd on the trailer when not attached to your vehicle, it might not matter. I leave equipment on my trailers regularly so the jack takes a lot of abuse.
The A frame jack is 5K. Don’t know rating on original, but suspect it’s higher.
As I said in the OP, GVWR is 7K, so 15% is 1050#. Even @ a full load (seldom to never) I’m covered with plenty of margin. The big factor for my use, is being able to have the box and spare, both mounted.