Originally Posted by Birdwatcher
Quote
Whether you intend it, or even realize it, this idea of "right and wrong" permeates every discussion of the War you engage in on this forum


Are you actually suggesting that notions of "right and wrong" did not permeate every discussion of the War among those folks who were actually engaged in it?

Both sides believed they were right, that being the tragedy of the thing.

Quote
You dismiss the Rebel soldiers as "useful idiots of the Rich Planters".


Where did I do this?

Although the question of 'dying to preserve the rich man's slaves' did often crop up as an issue across the South, especially after the application of the Confederate Draft Laws in '62.

There were many personal reasons on both side why a guy on either side would choose repeatedly to brave a storm of Minie balls and the awful consequences thereof.

I did suggest that if one accepts the notion that the Union soldier was merely Lincoln's stooge, this certainly applies in spades to the Southern soldier re: the uniformly wealthy Planter CLass leadership.

In fact if slavery was a poison that blighted everything it touched, the same might be said of the whole Southern Planter class. Look at the effect they had on the collective Antebellum South.

Birdwatcher


Odd (well, not really) how Mike keeps harping on the "wealthy planter class" of the South - who FOUGHT - and yet he says nothing about the wealthy industrial class in the North who bought themselves and their sons out of service by contribution to the Union coffers and payment of an Irish, Italian, or German immigrant to die in their place.

He is now accusing the "wealthy white planter class" of being a blight on the South/society. Not a peep about the Yankee industrialists, though. Hypocrisy at its finest, to say the least, and certainly trying to force "white guilt" upon any son of the South.

More of that intellectual dishonesty from the HS "teacher".

Last edited by 4ager; 07/26/15.
Originally Posted by Mannlicher
America needs to understand that our troops are not 'disposable'. Each represents a family; Fathers, Mothers, Sons, Daughters, Cousins, Uncles, Aunts... Our Citizens are our most valuable treasure; we waste far too many.