I've had only one HS Precision and now I'm up to four McMillans.
The HS Precision was pretty terrible. The felt recoil from the 30-06 was a marked increase, maybe the stock just didn't fit right. Then the finish (thicker than paint) began chipping off. If I were going to buy an aluminum bed stock again I would save the extra $150 over the HS and get a Bell and Carlson.
I have had a McMillan I didn't care for, a Hunter's Edge. I didn't like the comb drop, just never felt right.
Every other McMillan I've had has been pretty awesome. Thin grip, strong, light (I especially like the edge versions), stiff, etc.
