I'm sorry that Phil, who asked a question that was important to him, has to sit here and listen to the girls get their panties in a wad - or is it D size contest?

IMO Phil, either bullet will do just fine. I'd select the one that shoots the best in your rifle. Nosler and Sierra manuals list most accurate powders and loads - that's where I'd start. Personally, I'd also consider the Lapua 150 Scenar L. It should shoot very well also.