Yes,everything is a compromise. Do you mean you couldn't see that buck at all through your 6X42 Leupold? They are pretty good at light transmission.Could you not see the deer or not see the reticle,or perhaps both? I would think your eyes are holding you back more than your scope.

For your situation this woukld be my pick and I would learn to use the dots rather than dialing.
http://www.scopelist.com/kahles-kxi-35-10x50-illuminated-4d-dot.aspx

I wouldn't even consider changing scopes during a hunt. No way would I trust a return to perfect zero at longer distances.


The Leica is a great low light scope too,just a little larger with 30mm tube and heavier than the Kahles. I have not compared the Leica to the Kahles.
http://www.scopelist.com/leica-er-i-3-12x50-ballistic-56010-rifle-scope.aspx

Last edited by R_H_Clark; 02/16/17.