I have various 3x9's, a couple of 2x7's, the 3x12, and even a 5x15 that isn't on a gun at this time. I was just looking for something different. In fact, the scope I am trading is a Vortex Viper 3x9 which may be a better scope than either of those, but I'm just not crazy about BDC reticles. I listed several scopes that I'd trade for, but these two are the only offers I have and have pretty much committed to trading for one of them. Just trying to figure out which is the best of the two. Thanks for the responses so far.