I vote for old school. Remington 121, Winchester 61 or 62A would be tops on my list for a plinker/close rance huntin rig. Or a remington 511 or 512, super accurate with full size feel.
But Im a 22 super slut and have lots of em. The pumps are my fav for just all out fun to shoot.
Remington 512X
Winchester 62A