Sorry no reviews on neoshell, but I own westcomb event jacket and pants and also a kuiu chugach shell... If your wondering if you'll get wet from sitting in a puddle the answer is yes, that goes for ALL breathable rain gear....Breathability is great with all the pieces listed above and so is water resistance...The key is to keep the face fabric clean so it can breath and so the DWR can bead water.
If your hunting in continues rain for a weeks on end and think your going to be dry the whole time cause you spent $1000 on that latest and greatest rain gear.. Think again
All in all I think I like my kuiu shell the best cause its semi stretchable, all other things being equal, I would not hesitate to recommend either product.
Hope that helps
