Thanks Dirt, that backs up a search I did which indicated that the Old Bay Cafe was at the top of the list, 4.5 stars.
We've gone over to Clearwater Beach and eaten at Frenchie's Rockaway Grill twice. I found it OK, but it didn't wow me. I mean I can't get a grouper sandwich in Calgary, but the food was not something to die for.
Best seafood I've ever had was at Eric's Seafood in Kihei on Maui, in 1994 on our honeymoon. Kicked Mama's Seafood's ass, although the scenery at Mama's was better, IIRC Eric's was above the Denny's. We went to Eric's twice. On the second visit the restaurant was quite subdued. Turned out that Eric had been killed in a car accident the night before. Back then the highway between Kehei and Lahaina was only two lane and people would try risky passes of slower traffic. Glad to see that the road is twinned now. Eric's no longer exists to my knowledge, understandable as he was killed. The food was to die for.
Also, for the person who mentioned highway 4. We've been over to the Tampa area twice. Highway 4 can be high volume and much slower than you think. We now know to budget at least 2 hours to get where we want to go.
It's a 1PM gametime, Toronto at home against the Boston Redsox. Figure to have a nice seafood meal after the game, while we are on the coast.