Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Hunter's Campfire Can a state deport an illegal?

Idaho's house has just passed an immigration bill that would deport illegals to their home country. Can a state actually do that or is this just another feel good bill?
It also makes a first offense a misdemeanor and a 2d offense a felony.

if not, the State can always just send 'em to Chicago or NYC

If enough states do it there will be a change.

I don't think the Constitution addresses that so I would think they could but under the current Oligarchy I expect the DOJ to deny that right.

At the very least, they should take them to a border and toss them across. Most of Idaho's major highways cross borders in remote areas.

I'm betting they could treat them like the left treats Trump, and make them want to go home....

I’m not a legal expert, but I’m told that possession is 9/10ths of the law. If the Feds want to try to stop it, arrest them for interference with a peace officer.

Let’s find out how strong they “believe” in their cause.

Nida on this DOJ. This dark Uniparty deep state cabal is trying to forever fix their ruling class status by flooding the country with 10-15 mil “newcomers”, get them voting or at least counted by the Census.

They don’t care. Just power hungry. It’s all about them, not the country.

Same with all the reckless spending to buy votes. No regard for the growing debt and long term consequences.

Sad state of affairs and not sustainable.

DF

If the state legally detains an alien they can hold them for ICE to process and deport them.


If ICE doesn't deport them, I don't believe a state can. But I could be wrong about that. It happened once before.

I think you’re right.

But who runs ICE?

Yeah….

DF

They could bus them to Martha’s Vineyard.

DF

There’s only one way to find out.

The states are SOVEREIGN. They can and they should round up illegals, hold them in concentration camps, and export them directly to their country of origin with a bill sent to worthless FedGov.

Good post! Read the 10th Amendment. Off the top of my head.
“Powers not delegated to the government, are reserved to the states, and the people.”
A state absolutely has the right, and the responsibility, to protect its own interests from the fed gov. Especially if that fed gov is operating at the expense of the state!
Reon

I’d like to think so.

Charter a plane, fill it up with “migrants”, send it as far South as possible. Unload ‘em, refuel, head home.

Rinse and repeat. Just get ‘er done before the Feds find out.

I assume you mean land the plane, not unload at 30,000 feet....

I still like Martha's Vineyard.

DF

Do States really have rights?

Better yet, unload them at 30k over Martha's Vineyard.

Creative thinking.

I like that.

DF

Under this administration states have no rights. We should test that theory.

Idaho and other states start doing that and the Feds will just expedite giving them asylum and citizenship.

Put 50 wetbacks on a C-130 headed to Martha's Vineyard- - - - -and 20 parachutes. Depressurize the plane at 20K feet and lower the ramp. They'll have a couple of minutes, tops, to figure out who gets the parachutes before they all pass out from hypoxia.

These illegals ain’t going anywhere. They are here to stay and will be garnished with everything possible. Free stuff based on democratic.

I read recently that there are 51 million foreign born individuals living in the USA, large percentage , of course illegal in one form or other.ie expired visas, green cards and just plain illegal. Tell me the powers to be aren’t deliberately changing the demographics of America to their benefit. Remember Pat Buchanan, he wrote a book “the browning of America” over 30 years ago prophesied this very thing.’Mass deportation is the only answer.

I prefer the Deadwood solution.....Just making bacon, no fuss no muss.

I support fully the intent. But an honest question, can a state treat with a foreign nation on its own?

These people are not being persecuted in their home country because of their race, religion, nationality, participation in a certain social group or because of their political opinions.
They are coming here because they are too schitin to get off their sorry ass and go to work in their home country. A silver spoon awaits any that make it to Biden Country.
Between that and the mercenaries coming over by the hundreds our plate is full.

g

Trebuchet ?

I think it was last year a bill was introduced to empower states the ability to deport illegal aliens.

The fact it was introduced leads me to believe the feds do not currently allow or recognize the right of states to deport foreign nationals.

Much needs to change in the legislature.

Denver Colorado is begging illegals to go anywhere else but Colorado. Free Bus ticket

If the states can deport illegals, why isn’t Texas doing this instead of incurring the expense of sending them to northern cities? Just dump them back across the border.

The courts have been very reluctant to let the states enforce immigration directly. The courts thinking is if states are allowed to do this it will lead to a system that is not universal for the country. You may have states like Arizona and california that just let everyone in. Or states like Texas who let no one in. I can see why the courts have felt this way but that was when we had leadership at the federal level that at least gave an apperance of being interested in law enforcement. I think the courts need to do something or what they feared will actually be what happens anyways and we have a disfunctional system.

Texas has shipped out migrants to leftist cities by having the migrants agree to taking the trip. They have them sign paperwork consenting and its not forced. I see problems brewing between the states that threaten the country. For instance I think there needs to be a movement to remove New York from the county and kick them out. other states that fail to secure elections like wisconsin, georgia , arizona etc. may need some sort of punishment because their lack of law and out of control restraint and fraud effects the rest of us.

Untested because we’ve never been here at this level before.

It’s a grand plan to flood the country with future Dems so as to forever establish the Uniparty in power as envisioned by Deep State operatives.

So, we need to test what needs testing while there is still a hint of law in effect.

We’re getting dangerously close to the Venezuelan crevasse which is a one way trip, coming back not easy, maybe not possible.

Seems we’re at a tipping point, “A republic if we can keep it”. Ben Franklin saw the crevasse, hoped we’d be able to stay clear of it.

DF

No.

It’s a jurisdiction issue; the question is whether states can enforce federal law. Ripe for litigation.

Particularly when the Feds abdicate their responsibility and the state declares an invasion. That’s new ground for the law, soon to get plowed.

DF

Texas if I understand it right, is going to arrest them (the new law that has the Communist insane) then allow them to voluntarily go across the River or face a sentence in the prison. Suspended Sentence kind of deal to not return.

Tipping point? 50+ years ago maybe. 90% of the dumb fuggs here beleive we are a democracy, and they think they are Patriots ! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Scuttle the ship. All is lost.

What river are you talking about, we don't want them either, and that many may turn us blue, you want that?

Unload at 30,000 ft. OVER Obama's Martha's vineyard compound, or better yet over Biden's Delaware beach house digs.

I’m thinking Rio Grande, not Sabine.

No, we for sure don’t want them any more than Texas.

DF

Of course the Rio...not the Red or Sabine. Tighten them Cajun wires up in the melon.

Having the weekend morning shows on 94.9 Gumbo go from Swamp Pop changing French to Spanish is not in The Plan.

Well, in CA. They PREVENTED ICE from deporting illegals.

How did these scum get these big houses on the beaches and still cry global warming. It's a scam And these useful idiots are eating every ounce of it.

Just make their holding cell zero degrees F.- - - - -that way they can BE ice when ICE takes custody of the worthless scumbags.

Yeah, if the oceans were gonna rise from ice melt, you’d think they wouldn’t be living in ocean front mansions.

DF