NIKON PROSTAFF - 480 CLICKS OF CAN-DO!
 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 >
Topic Options
#4867696 - 01/27/11 How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range?
DayPacker Offline
Campfire Ranger

Registered: 01/16/09
Posts: 1905
Loc: Front Range, Co
How much energy is generally required to kill an elk with any given caliber? What is the cut off to stop shooting at an elk and expect it to die when hit in the heart and lungs?
_________________________
Time spent hunting is not deducted from one's lifetime.


Top
RV 728 BP
#4867717 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: DayPacker]
djs Offline
Campfire Kahuna

Registered: 01/18/06
Posts: 18904
Loc: CO
I believe that 1,500 foot pounds of energy delivered at the target is traditionally considered minimal. I read this in P.O. Ackley's writings, but this was before the wide-spread use of modern controlled-expansion bullets.

Of course, folks have used 243 Winchesters and 30-30's and been successful - can only guess at the wounded game rate.

Top
#4867738 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: djs]
rattler Offline
Campfire Oracle

Registered: 11/07/03
Posts: 28592
Loc: NE Montana
no minimum.....if the bullet punches deep enough to disrupt the plumbing the critter dies......the whole minimum energy thing becomes real stupid once you realize ppl kill the damn things with arrows......phuck up the plumbing and you have a dead elk.....
_________________________
A serious student of the "Armchair Safari" always looking for Africa/Asia hunting books

Top
#4867739 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: djs]
wadevb1 Offline
Campfire Regular

Registered: 09/16/05
Posts: 1383
Loc: Michigan
I'm no expert, but I've seen plenty of long range videos showing elk dropping in their tracks from the little 6.5x284.

Then again, they probably don't publish their wounded/lost footage.

Top
#4867749 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: wadevb1]
Royce Offline
Campfire Guide

Registered: 12/28/03
Posts: 4743
Loc: zip code 59602
If you are 3 miles from the truck, it's 20 below and uphill over talus slope to the truck, it takes a bunch of energy

Top
#4867763 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: Royce]
bea175 Online   content
Campfire Oracle

Registered: 02/15/02
Posts: 30172
Loc: Kpt.,TN , Montgomery, Co, VA
I believe energy is irrelevant , you put a hole through both lungs and let the air out and they won't go far regardless of cal or energy.
_________________________
Where does the spirit go when you die ?

Top
#4867851 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: bea175]
Royce Offline
Campfire Guide

Registered: 12/28/03
Posts: 4743
Loc: zip code 59602
This is one of those questions that has no answer- It's similar to asking "How much gas does it takes to get to the grocery store" without knowing where the person lives, what he drives or which grocery store he goes to.

Top
#4867865 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: Royce]
noKnees Online   content
Campfire Tracker

Registered: 11/09/05
Posts: 5003
Loc: johnstown, NY/Bloomfield CT
I think its velocity not energy that is the key metric. You need enough to expand your bullet when it hits. If you carry enough velocity/energy to expand a hunting bullet you likely have enough for a broadside shot on most animals. Some bullets may require a little less but I would say a good bullet in a reasonable caliber at 2000fps should kill most things hit well.
_________________________
The collection of taxes which are not absolutely required, which do not beyond reasonable doubt contribute to public welfare, is only a species of legalized larceny. Under this Republic the rewards of industry belong to those who earn them. Coolidge

Top
#4867874 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: Royce]
Seafire Offline
Campfire Kahuna

Registered: 04/21/04
Posts: 24311
Loc: Southern Oregon USA
I managed to drop a 650 lb, 11 yr old cow elk, with a 165 grain 30 cal Ballistic tip, at 175yds that left the muzzle at 2250 fps.

destroyed both lungs, cut the esophagus and blew up the upper half of its liver.

it was at a dead run and made it another 60 yds or so, and then collapsed.

don't think we were dealing with big energy figures there..
_________________________





Top
#4867895 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: noKnees]
smokepole Online   content
Campfire Kahuna

Registered: 06/30/06
Posts: 18057
Loc: Colorado
Originally Posted By: noKnees
I think its velocity not energy that is the key metric. You need enough to expand your bullet when it hits. If you carry enough velocity/energy to expand a hunting bullet you likely have enough for a broadside shot on most animals. Some bullets may require a little less but I would say a good bullet in a reasonable caliber at 2000fps should kill most things hit well.


Good concept for centerfires but doesn't apply to 400-grain .50-caliber bullets from muzzleloaders at around 1500-1600 MV, with well under 1,000 ft.-lbs at reasonable ranges.
_________________________

A wise man is frequently humbled.


Top
#4867904 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: smokepole]
jnyork Online   content
Campfire Outfitter

Registered: 03/05/08
Posts: 8749
Loc: Wyoming and Arizona
The well-placed shot is the key to it all, instead of worrying about "energy" start worrying about your marksmanship and hunting skills used to get close enough for a sure-thing clean shot. Bowhunters and flintlock shooters kill elk, but they know how to hunt and shoot.
_________________________

Top
#4868004 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: jnyork]
denton Online   content
Campfire Outfitter

Registered: 06/28/04
Posts: 8293
Loc: Utah
As has been said on this thread:

Energy is a poor indicator of killing power.

The key is to punch about a 1/2" or larger hole through vital plumbing.

With spitzer type bullets, penetration is remarkably constant over a pretty broad operating range. If impact speed is in that range, it does not matter whether the bullet came from a 30-30 or a 300 RUM, the result will be essentially the same.

Most standard cup and core bullets need at least 2100 FPS at impact, and no more than 2800 FPS at impact. Partitions, for example, open at 1800 FPS and make about the same length wound channel to over 3200 FPS. Pay attention to keeping your bullet's impact speed within its design range, and you'll get pretty uniform results.

Use a standard bullet for a close in shot at 3000 FPS, and you're begging for problems.

More muzzle velocity does not get you deader critters. It gets you a longer, flatter trajectory.
_________________________
It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong. Richard P. Feynman

Top
#4868016 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: bea175]
Tom264 Offline
Campfire Kahuna

Registered: 12/19/06
Posts: 21754
Loc: above you.....
Originally Posted By: bea175
I believe energy is irrelevant , you put a hole through both lungs and let the air out and they won't go far regardless of cal or energy.
I concur, its all about bullet construction and placement...energy smenergy.
_________________________

Top
#4868020 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: rattler]
Rock Chuck Offline
Campfire Oracle

Registered: 01/05/06
Posts: 33978
Loc: Filer, ID
Originally Posted By: rattler
no minimum.....if the bullet punches deep enough to disrupt the plumbing the critter dies......the whole minimum energy thing becomes real stupid once you realize ppl kill the damn things with arrows......phuck up the plumbing and you have a dead elk.....

You can't compare a bullet to an arrow. The mode of killing is totally different. An arrow cuts as it goes through and penetration is much more unless it hits a big bone.

An arrow lacks the energy of a bullet, but it has much more momentum because of it's much greater weight.
_________________________
Eat your food as your medicines.
Otherwise you have to eat medicines as your food.

Top
#4868099 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: Rock Chuck]
ironbender Online   happy
Campfire Oracle

Registered: 12/08/03
Posts: 48070
Loc: In the shadow of the Kenai Mtn...
Originally Posted By: Rock Chuck
An arrow cuts as it goes through...

A bullet rips and tears as it goes through....
_________________________
If you take the time it takes, it takes less time.
--Pat Parelli

American by birth; Alaskan by choice.


Top
#4868136 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: DayPacker]
jwp475 Offline
Campfire Kahuna

Registered: 04/25/05
Posts: 20244
Loc: USA
Originally Posted By: DayPacker
How much energy is generally required to kill an elk with any given caliber? What is the cut off to stop shooting at an elk and expect it to die when hit in the heart and lungs?



The amount of energy is a moot point, because energy numbers will not rate terminal performance. A better question to ask is "How much penetration is required and how large of a wound channel to effectively take an Elk"
_________________________

I got banned on another web site for a debate that happened on this site. That's a first

Top
#4868141 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: smokepole]
ironeagle_84 Offline
Campfire 'Bwana

Registered: 08/31/08
Posts: 10443
Loc: grants pass, oregon
dont shoot beyond your limitations, and use a suitable caliber.

thats how much energy is required.
_________________________
30-06 till i die, the greatest round ever!

I carry a gun because a cop is too heavy!

CEO of a Turdlike People: Turds & Tats Division... (per Ingwe grin )

Top
#4868147 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: Rock Chuck]
jwp475 Offline
Campfire Kahuna

Registered: 04/25/05
Posts: 20244
Loc: USA
Originally Posted By: Rock Chuck
Originally Posted By: rattler
no minimum.....if the bullet punches deep enough to disrupt the plumbing the critter dies......the whole minimum energy thing becomes real stupid once you realize ppl kill the damn things with arrows......phuck up the plumbing and you have a dead elk.....

You can't compare a bullet to an arrow. The mode of killing is totally different. An arrow cuts as it goes through and penetration is much more unless it hits a big bone.

An arrow lacks the energy of a bullet, but it has much more momentum because of it's much greater weight.



The mode of killing is the same wheather arrow or bullet, they both kill by massive hemorage and or by taking out the cental nervous system. No magic
_________________________

I got banned on another web site for a debate that happened on this site. That's a first

Top
#4868148 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: Royce]
Folically_Challenged Online   content
Campfire Guide

Registered: 05/22/07
Posts: 3682
Loc: Hamiltucky, OH
Originally Posted By: Royce
If you are 3 miles from the truck, it's 20 below and uphill over talus slope to the truck, it takes a bunch of energy


Harumph !!!!!!!!!!!!!

FC
_________________________
Trashing the West is like tapping a maple tree for its syrup — lucrative and tasty as long as too many holes do not kill the host. - Victor Davis Hanson

Top
#4868205 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: jwp475]
rattler Offline
Campfire Oracle

Registered: 11/07/03
Posts: 28592
Loc: NE Montana
Originally Posted By: jwp475
Originally Posted By: Rock Chuck
Originally Posted By: rattler
no minimum.....if the bullet punches deep enough to disrupt the plumbing the critter dies......the whole minimum energy thing becomes real stupid once you realize ppl kill the damn things with arrows......phuck up the plumbing and you have a dead elk.....

You can't compare a bullet to an arrow. The mode of killing is totally different. An arrow cuts as it goes through and penetration is much more unless it hits a big bone.

An arrow lacks the energy of a bullet, but it has much more momentum because of it's much greater weight.



The mode of killing is the same wheather arrow or bullet, they both kill by massive hemorage and or by taking out the cental nervous system. No magic



yep, end result is the same, drop in blood pressure to the brain....arrow or bullet, interrupt blood flow to the brain and the critter dies......both get the exact same result just use different methods of propulsion to get there.....
_________________________
A serious student of the "Armchair Safari" always looking for Africa/Asia hunting books

Top
#4868233 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: rattler]
Rock Chuck Offline
Campfire Oracle

Registered: 01/05/06
Posts: 33978
Loc: Filer, ID
The arrow cuts through the blood vessels and nerves. A bullet blasts it's way through. I heard of a guy who killed an elk with an arrow on a really lousy shot - he hit it in the lower leg. It bled out and he recovered it several miles away. I doubt you'd find most animals that badly hit with a bullet.
_________________________
Eat your food as your medicines.
Otherwise you have to eat medicines as your food.

Top
#4868238 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: Rock Chuck]
jwp475 Offline
Campfire Kahuna

Registered: 04/25/05
Posts: 20244
Loc: USA
Originally Posted By: Rock Chuck
The arrow cuts through the blood vessels and nerves. A bullet blasts it's way through. I heard of a guy who killed an elk with an arrow on a really lousy shot - he hit it in the lower leg. It bled out and he recovered it several miles away. I doubt you'd find most animals that badly hit with a bullet.



I've seen animals hit in the ham bleed out rather quickly when the femal artery is crushed by a bullet
_________________________

I got banned on another web site for a debate that happened on this site. That's a first

Top
#4868241 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: smokepole]
CCCC Offline
Campfire Tracker

Registered: 09/11/08
Posts: 6150
Loc: New Mexico High Country
Answer may depend upon whether you are going to shoot it in the eye/brain, through the gut, or somewhere in between. IMHO, placement is much more important than any specific fps or terminal ft. lbs.
_________________________
NRA Member - Life, Benefactor, Patron

Top
#4868247 - 01/27/11 Re: How much energy is needed to kill an elk down range? [Re: DayPacker]
Vic_in_Va Offline
Campfire Tracker

Registered: 05/30/02
Posts: 6070
As has been stated earlier, bullet construction is more important than energy figures. Deer season '09, I had a harder time killing a deer at 30 yards with a .308 loaded with 150 grain SSTs at 2800 fps at the muzzle, than I did killing a deer at 236 yards with a .30-30 loaded with 170 grain FPs at 2184 fps at the muzzle. There was a vast difference in the amount of energy at impact, but the .30-30 still made a through and through hole, with signs of expansion. The SST blew up on impact.

The following year proved a change of bullet in the .308 was all that was needed.

With Elk, it's important to choose a bullet that will drive in deep and break things. (cough, cough, TSX, cough) Elk are more demanding of bullet integrity than a Whitetail deer.

Top
Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 >

Moderator:  RickBin, SYSOP 
RV 180 2
RV 160 1 2
RV 160 2 2
Who's Online
503 registered (19rabbit52, 1lessdog, 257robertsimp, 257wbymagkiller, 1234, 1Longbow, 52 invisible), 1209 Guests and 673 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
RV 160 3 2
Forum Stats
55,815 Registered Members
73 Forums
744,162 Topics
10,808,376 Posts

Most users ever online: 4,830 @ 12/02/14










Copyright © 2000-2016 24hourcampfire.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved.