Democracy is not freedom. Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to eat for lunch. Freedom comes from the recognition of certain rights which may not be taken, not even by a 99% vote. *Marvin Simkin* L.A. Times (1992)
I've only seen 2-3 mulies over 180 in the field. They definitely stand out as most 160-170 class bucks look really big too me, but when they break over 180 they are in a totally different class. You'll know after you've seen some good bucks.
RHutch; You have already been shown a lot of very, very good mulie bucks. Congratulations to all the successful hunters on the wonderful examples.
Though you may not have time to look over the prospective buck for too long, sometimes one gets a bit of a longer look with mule deer - though admittedly sometimes from quite far away.
Anyway, one of the ways that we've found make it easier to judge antler size is knowing what the average ear width spread should be on an adult buck in the area you'll be hunting.
From talking to folks in the know I've been given to understand this can vary a fair bit actually from region to region. For instance we're quite hot here in southern BC, so the ear spread on an adult buck will typically be about this:
If the buck's antlers are inside or outside the ears then, one can get a rough spread quite easily.
As well it will follow that knowing the approximate length of the individual ear will give you a quick comparison gauge for tine length.
In the end though in all likelihood I'd be just as happy with a bit of a character rack with a bunch of kickers even if it didn't add to a numerical target - but that's just me. So I'd encourage you to have a good time and shoot a buck that satisfies your personal goals - whatever they may be.
Hopefully that makes sense and is some use to you on your hunt. All the best luck to you in what sounds like a great place to start hunting mule deer.
It was actually 176 6/8 gross. Don't do nets usually. We killed him a few days later a few miles from where I took the pic.... Massive body on this buck....322 lbs on cotton scales.
It is irrelevant what you think. What matters is the TRUTH.
Body size will deceive people, especially if they're used to typical bucks weighing no more than 250 pounds live weight, typical of much mule deer country in eastern Montana and Wyoming.
I almost didn't shoot one of the biggest bucks I've taken because his body made his antlers look rather ordinary. Turned out he weighed at least 350 on the hoof, and maybe 400. There weren't any scales 20 miles back in the mountains, but the boned meat from his carcass weighed around 125 pounds, and the live weight of hoofed big game animals is normally just about three times the weight of the boned meat. His antlers grossed 200.
“Montana seems to me to be what a small boy would think Texas is like from hearing Texans.” John Steinbeck
Thanks GregW. Here's a couple more of this buck taken through my spotter from a long ways.........2 days before the season started 2009. He was an ancient buck too and had likely seen his better days.
JB, I know what you mean about body size. I've been fooled several times too, and I grew up out here chasing these darn things!
It is irrelevant what you think. What matters is the TRUTH.
It was actually 176 6/8 gross. Don't do nets usually. We killed him a few days later a few miles from where I took the pic.... Massive body on this buck....322 lbs on cotton scales.