I completely understand and respect your points of view....mine is different
I have a judge and have shot it numerous times with .45LC as well as several different types of .410
with the short barrel of the public defender, I do not expect it to perform out to 20 or 30 yards, however, it does VERY well at closer ranges....I have killed several annoying tree rats and a few armadillos from the stand with it
Also, I have patterned Remington's 00 buck and winchester's PDX1 and both pattern superb at self defense range....in fact, I would imagine both would be far more devastating in a single shot than most self defense calibers
I have had ZERO failures to fire in SA and DA....no malfunctions whatsoever
I did not but this gun for CC...I bought it for my trips in the field and so far, it has served its purpose well
The Public Defender is a lot different than the ones I had. Mine were full size chambered for 3". There are so many different models of the Judge that I hate making a blanket statement, yet that was my experience with the two examples I had, which were identical 3" barreled, full stainless models. The Public Defender may very well not exhibit the problems I had. I would certainly test it double action though.
I never had problems with the Raging Judge I had either. It's hardly a concealed carry piece though and I shot it very sparingly double action. lol