I am voting for my BSA majestic featherweight, it's light, accurate, powerful, light recoil (ported barrel), very slick and its feel right at home in my hands.
A Matthews MQ1 70lb draw, 65% let off slinging some Bemans with Rages! Wrong forum but nothing makes my heart pump like outsmarting a deer's nose and successfully harvesting one up close and personal.
Just messing with you guys! I've killed whitetails with a few different rifles. Don't know if it's the best or not, but definitely my most memorable rifle was a Remington 7600 pump 30-06 with a Redfield scope that I saved for and bought myself. The rifle is long gone and I couldn't begin to tell you how it grouped. But, It dropped my first deer, a 4 pointer, in bitter cold weather. It was so cold, my uncle had icicles formed in his mustache. I remember it like it was yesterday (many years ago). The deer were hunkered down in thick cutover and you had to step on them like rabbits. He came out the hole running. I took a quick offhand swing shot and took his lower jaw off. He got to his feet and I finished him off with #2 in the chest. Had to drag that deer nearly a mile to the truck...won't no atv's in them days! It was all about the kill, and that was some of the best back straps I've ever had!
I love to bow hunt but I also love to shoot anything that will go boom! I don't rifle hunt a lot anymore, but I can't wait to shoot one with my new Tikka 270 next fall. New guns make me feel like a kid again...sure some of you can relate. Most of all I have come to revere the whitetail as one of the most majestic animals on God's green earth and I cherish every minute I get in the deer woods. It's even more special nowadays because I get to share my passion and time afield with my young son. For me, that's what hunting is all about.
Sorry, I got carried away with the trip down memory lane. Please ignore me and carry on.
After reading the thread about F&S choices it is obvious that everyone has an opinion and no doubt no one is probably really wrong. Whitetails are found in a great many varying degrees of habitat so that without a doubt can influence some peoples choice. Without getting too technical on what that habitat is, let's have it grouped into "woods" and "more open". I realize this is pretty broad but I think it will get a good cross section of what various people consider the "Best". If you want to include both habitats and two different rifles, fine. If only one or the other, fine also. Let's just keep it to one rifle for each though with the caliber optional.
So, with that in mind, lets see what your "Best" whitetail rifle of all time is.
"An archer sees how far he can be from a target and still hit it, a bowhunter sees how close he can get before he shoots." It is certainly easy to use that same line of thinking with firearms. -- Unknown