I decided to make my Model 19 6" my new go to backpacking gun, so I'll be in the market for a holster.

In past threads I have heard mention that many prefer a shoulder holster as opposed to a belt holster, has anyone had a problem with such a set-up with a backpack on? I'm thinking about a vertical carry model since the revolver has a 6" barrel.

Is it a pain having the pack straps so close to the revolver, either on the hike, or putting the pack on and off?

What do most prefer out on the trail, a shoulder or a belt model?

I asked this over on the "Handgun" forum also, maybe we can consolidate the replies over there.
Same thread, Handgun Forum

Thank you.

I don't like putting a backpack on over a shoulder holster, nor have I had any happiness putting one on over a belt holster. Best I've come up with is a paddle holster slipped over the waist belt, cross-draw fashion.

Dennis

Dennis,

Are the chest rigs comfortable? I'm thinking of ordering the "Chesty Puller" chest rig and a holster from these guys when I get my Blackhawk.

Simply rugged

Travis

Would you wear binoculars with that chesty puller set-up?

I don't know, I've never tried one on. Are they a PITA?

Travis

I couldn't tell you, but from pictures it looks as if the revolver would ride right on top of my binos. I wouldn't want to lose the option of wearing binos on scouting trips.

I was looking at it for a backpacking/fishing rig.

Travis

Friend, you have just done me a big favor, though perhaps not my wallet . I'd not seen that website before, nor have I tried any of their gear. I'll likely be sending them some coin in the new year, though. The Chesty Puller rig looks like it might could work out.

Thanks,

Dennis

My buddy said Taffin did a little blurb on their leather and said good things FWIW.

I think those prices look pretty fair considering what I paid for a Bianchi a couple years ago.

Travis

Certainly comparable to Galco. I'll have to ask some folks from up north what they know about the gear and the outfit.

Dennis

Let me know if you don't mind. I'm waiting for that .44 Special Flattop Lipseys is running so I probably won't order the leather for another month.


Travis

El Paso Saddlery has a "Tanker" holster that can be adjusted to ride low on the ribcage, sort of a compromise between a vertical shoulder holster and a chest rig -

El Paso Saddlery Tanker

If you carry binoculars, they would probably hang below your sternum, to one side of the holster.

(Holster has a belt loop, but it can be cut off or ignored if you want to wear this holster outside a jacket...)

I use a Blackhawk CQB with the paddle attached. It slides over the strap on the waist belt and rides right where a handgun should.

Bianchi paddle, rides nice on the pack belt.

+1 Browtine. This is how I carry my G-30 But mine is a Glaco hard plastic.

i packed a 4" 629 for a lot of years prospecting and mapping in northern BC and the yukon. I could never really make a shoulder or chest holster comfortable with a pack on as well, and settled on a nylon holster on the pack belt like Browtine shows above.

I use a Bianchi UM-84R with a flap and the metal molle(?) attachement, which makes it easy to pop off the pack and onto your belt. it aso gives better protection and retention when bushwhacking.

Another guy I know uses the flap holster on his pack belt, and wears a simply rugged pancake on his belt which will lay flat and un-noticed, then simply moves the gun onto his hip when he puts the pack down. Not exactly convenient, but anything will be a compromise when you are dealing with a pistol, a backpack, binoculars, rain-gear, and other doo-dads on your belt and neck.

Has anyone tried the military combat type holsters that hold the gun on the leg? I have thought about using one but didn't want to spend the cash when what I have works.

You might consider one of these, has the advantage of keeping the handgun clean and dry, and it's also discreet:

http://store.thewilderness.com/index.php?cPath=51

I bought a Guides Choice Holster made by Dave Johnston of Diamond D Custom Leather that Im very happy with. I think it may be what you are looking for.
Heres a link

http://www.davidjohnstonleather.com/Pages/GuidesChoice.html

What I do is either slip a holster on to the straps of my waist belt, like the one shown here or simply put the pistol in the top pocket of the pack. No special holster is required for either my Bianchi Endurance Pack or either of my Kifarus.
If the holster is attached to the pack, it works best for me to pull the handgun out of the holster if I'm removing the pack. Otherwise it swings around and bumps stuff, etc.
Putting it in the top pocket is what I like during the off season. The "greenies" I run into don't get nervous and nobody knows I have one. Don't need to remove it when I remove the pack etc. If you try this, make sure you can get at the handgun quickly. If the pack is a low riding one, this may not work well enough for you. E

Those look nice, do you know if the holsters in those set-ups can be taken off the strap set up and used on a belt around your hip?

Looks like it can be adjusted low enough to ride below my glasses.

I'll have to give them a call and ask some questions.

I took the model 19 6" to the range for the first time and shot some +p .38 through it, it felt like I was shooting a .22; about half the recoil of my old .45.

Depends on the pack.

My old Kelty carries very nicely with a 4-5/8" or 5.5" barreled Ruger single action in a (Uncle Mike's) shoulder holster under a jacket. I set it up so the bottom of the jacket and the pack straps really control the gun, not so much the holster straps.

I actually prefer putting the gun in the top compartment with the cinch slightly loose. I lay it in there with the muzzle to the left with the gun on it's side such that the butt is nearer to me. I can reach up behind my head and draw reasonably quickly. Gun is out of the weather, out of sight, out of my probably sweaty armpit, and quite accessible.

With my pack frame (Cabela's alaska guide) there's a gap behind my right hip where I can carry that same gun pretty comfortably between myself and the padded waist belt in a conventional holster. (This also works with the Kelty depending on load.)

I have not found a good solution for an internal frame pack like the Badlands 2200 I bought last fall. With a long barreled single action I can put the gun muzzle-down between the 2 layers of the waist band. Gotta keep an eye on it so it doesn't try to escape, though, and I have no solution at all for a short barreled gun. With a cross-chest stablizer strap and more centered shoulder pads, the shoulder holster does not work well for me.

Tom