It looks like the Starline is the heavy type you'd want if they got the alloy/hardness right. I've had excellent luck with Starline in heavy handgun loads.
What was the problem with the LC brass?
I am mostly by a very large extent a handguner. Starline is all I use there.
LC brass problem:
Variance in neck stickiness so bad that it would split in the thin area on first firing. His chamber is good. Felt a wide variance with my Lee Auto-Prime when priming. Like I said, he might have gotten a bad batch. Once is enough for me.