For us, at home no question he walks. At the lease where the genetics are not as good, he walks too. Have seen plenty like that this year so far. Not quite old enough for us and the deer pictured is not old enough for us either.
That said its not my call and not a question I would ask of others. Make a decision and run with it.
The one good thing about not shooting is he is out there breeding more hopefully and getting older is at least a 50/50 shot.
