All great looking and performing knives trout. I'll have to say though that I recently received a Winston #43 with the radius on the spine and I have really grown fond of that knife. I makes for a very comfortable feel and work-ability. So for me, in this case anyway, it would be 1) Winston, 2) Dowell and 3) Ingram in order of preference.
Whatever you decide, it's a tough one.
