I have and like both. The 1885 high walls with the 28 inch barrel are heavy. I have used one in the past and didn't enjoy carrying it. The 22 and 24 inch barrel models carry better but still feel heavy. The 1885 low wall rifles are a delight to carry and shoot. All my 1885's have been accurate without any alterations. I currently have a #1 RSI in 6.5x55. Somewhat surprisingly to me, it is the most consistently accurate of the six #1's I've owned and shoots about as well as the 1885's. With the 20 inch barrel, it is a great, quick handling hunting rifle. None of my #1's have been horrible shooters but none, until the RSI, have been outstanding.
