i have not shot that exact bullet either but I have shot and seen shot multiple whitetails with sierra bullets and they work just fine never had a problem harvesting my deer....the bullet you reference in my mind would be great for whitetails as sierra builds their hollow point game bullets a little tougher with a thicker jacket than their regular hunting bullets.....I really do not know how we killed deer before all these super bullets came along .....just because they may be better doesnt mean they are needed or that the old cup and core bullet doesnt work...