I like the suggestion of wool gloves. I had a pair of wool gloves with the fold-over mitten end many years ago. Only the tip of the right finger was exposed. They were great in snow and/or cold weather. I'm going to look for something like that. Hard to find these days it seems.

I brought 4 pair of gloves with me to Idaho last year. Two of them were Gore-Tex but they soaked through. All 4 of us had issues with boots, gloves or rain gear on that trip.

Affordable Sportfishing Charters and Cruises out of Noank CT - https://www.rowdygirlcharters.com/