Not sure. Perhaps go to a Home Depot or similar and try some of the screws they have? Otherwise, a fasterner specialty like Fastenal. Fastenal is all things screws, nuts, bolts, washers, etc. Course you'd have to got there and let them try to fit a screw into it.
Maybe try call them tomorrow. Bet they'd just send you a new one.
Contact Us Via Phone: +1 (434) 929-2800
