I would choose the heavier arrow and preference would be a 200gr Cutthroat. Those broadheads are heck for stout and have used the same head to kill multiple deer and turkeys.

My second favorite broadhead is a VPA 3 blade. Same as above, and punched a 250gr, 550 gr arrows out of 4828 longbow clear through a deer earlier this month. I do pull 29.5 inches though.

Arcus Venator