Thanks Sheister... My experience with rottenstone has been that it increases shine and gloss rather than knocking it down...do you have a certain technique for decreasing shine with the rottenstone?
I have had the same results and have gone back over a stock with a grey 3m pad or 4F pumice to knock the shine down. But usually use the rottenstone and then wax the stock with a bees wax/carnuba wax and use minimal buffing for a satin sheen.
