Originally Posted by GunGeek
Originally Posted by JGray
One quick observation on cylinder length is it appears the Lyman 170 gr Keith SWC will be too long in 357 brass and I'll have to use 38 Spl brass for that bullet.
Not a fan of that bullet. It's not all that great on game and it doesn't fit most .357's. But you have to keep in mind, it wasn't actually designed for the .357 mag, it was designed for the .38/44 High Speed cartridge. Elmer used it in a 6.5" S&W Outdoorsman given to him by Daniel Wesson.
I will say it is accurate though.


A lot of game has been taken the 170 grain Keith and it penetration is excellent



I got banned on another web site for a debate that happened on this site. That's a first