Guys:

My daughter needs a shotgun for bird hunting
20 gauge
She is 13, 5-4 1/2 and still growing, I would guess 5-7
She is thin, 90-95lb at the moment
She is recoil sensitive
I am trying to get her a decent gun for life

I have narrowed it down to an Apple and an Orange

One choice is a CZ redhead premier reduced length Overunder
5.7lb
41” oal
13inch length of pull
24” barrels

The other choice is a Franchi SemiAuto affinity catalyst
5.7lb
46” oal
13 7/8 length of pull
26” barrel

O/U pros: simple to use
Safe, break the barrel when not in action
Dad can use it?
Con: 2 shots, sharper kick

SemiAuto: pro: softer recoil
The Franchi Catalyst has a stock specifically designed for a woman and includes a shim kit
4+1
Cons: more complex loading, safety, cleaning

The price is about the same
There are some pros and cons I am sure

What do you guys think?