Scott I went through the same issues when I ordered my VM-2. I went horsehide on the holster and the Milt Sparks wonderfully built belt. The difference for me came down to wear during the summer months here. I work up a good lather all year but especially so when it gets oppressively hot. My cowhide holsters whether pocket or iwb really soak through with sweat but the horsehide is rather sweat repellant. Hope this helps.
