I can't compare the newer Marlins with the Henry. But did own two of the "JM" Marlins in 45-70 and they were without a doubt the worse lever actions I ever owned in my life. Both had feeding issues and would bind up every time I took them to the range. On more than one occasion had to take them apart at the range just to get the ammo out.
Been keeping my eyes open for one of the new Remlins as I would like to purchase one to see if they have improved. The quality of the wood fitment seems to be improving. If I bought a new Remlin would do so in person so I could examine the wood to metal fit.
On to the Henrys, own a 45-70 and love it! Never had any issues with it and if I did their customer support is some of the best out there. My vote goes for the Henry.
