Home Forums Birds & Dogs Shotguns Ithaca Side by Side

I've got an old Ithaca 16 gauge. Needs a stock refinish. Light and nice.

Model and pictures?

I have a 20-gauge Ithaca Flues made in 1923. 26" barrels, Imp. Cyl/Mod., double triggers. I use it for snipe hunting with 2.5" low-pressure shells from Polywad in Roberta, GA. However, I am just finding out that Polywad may not be in business any longer. These old Ithacas are known for throwing beautiful patterns, and mine does! It is recommended that you shoot low pressure shells in yours, hope we both can find a source.

Sorry, I just noticed they are out of stock on 16 gauge, 2-1/2" shells.

RST has essentially been shut down for over a year with the supply issues.

A gorgeous 16 gauge NID called my name from the rack at a small gunshop one day. It went home with me and I enjoyed it for several years. Unfortunately, it was calling my brother's name all that time and now resides with him. That's okay, I've got his Browning Double Automatic.

Eventually, the forend lug came loose from the barrels on the Ithaca. (My brother only has the use of his right arm, and the uncontrolled recoil impulse has worked strange mischief on a few shotguns, including the above mentioned Browning which is why I've got it now.) I drilled and countersunk a clearance hole for an 8-32 or 10-32 machine screw up through the forend lug and, from there spotted a hole to tap in the rib for the screw, screwed the lug on through the rib, cut the screw of and made it invisible from above with a needle file, and life went on happily ever after with that gun.

I hate a two timing gun, one that calls me and someone else as well....lol.

A nice NID 16 is sort of on my wish list. I’ve come close a few times but never “pulled the trigger “.

My present NID is a 30 inch 12ga. With nicer than average wood and checkering for a Field Grade, it may be a Special Field model. The barrels are not heavy and it points like a dream. I load it with bismuth when ducks are on the agenda. If geese are expected I usually take a different gun, not wanting to expose it to goose load recoil. The action is plenty strong but it still has 85 yr old wood. The one time I took it on a goose hunt I shot two doubles on Giant Canadas. Long story but a memorable day.

That Sir is a great idea!

Talk about "whispering your name"!
Rem "Sportsman", 16 gauge. S/N suggests it was one of the first 500 made in 1932. Well used, but not mistreated!
Had shoulder replacement surgery in 2019. Doc said, "Easy on the recoil"!.
I passed the Rem 870 12 bore to the youngest.
This old beauty is still a bit much. A couple of rounds during turkey season isn't bad, but I still wouldn't want to shoot a round of skeet with it! LOL!

After 2 shoulder surgery's, I gave up the 12 ga on turkey and went to a 20 ga. Wish I had done it long before I did.

Very nice pullit, enjoy!

My dad and I back when I was 12. We were in Huron, SD and I was using dad's Ithaca Flues Model 1 1/2 12 gauge. Case color on receiver, nice floral engraving, kicked like a mule! Lol! The stock had been shortened and even at 12, didn't fit me for beans. Didn't stop me though...



Enjoy your 16ga, very nice!

thanks Dean, an ill fitting shotgun is no fun to shoot for sure, kicks like a rented mule. When you are young, you can handle recoil better, or at least I could.

I even went so far as to pick up a Mossberg bolt action .410 to cut down on recoil! LOL! Ten rounds of #9 TSS shot in .410 cost me $60!!! 🤯 Sure would like to take at least ONE turkey with that setup!

At what date would it be safe to have reamed for 3" shells?
After a certain serial number?
I see these from time to time.

Why do that at all? Pheasants, ducks and geese can easily be killed with 2 3/4in shells. Lead or Bismuth, of course.

Not trying to tell you what to do, but I can truthfully say that I never killed anything with a 3" shell that I could not have killed with a 2 3/4" shell.
Just something to think about .

If I found a suitable donor. I'd likely get screw in chokes, lengthened forcing cones, might as well add 3 inch chambers for turkey.

Ness, just for your information. I had a very nice Browning S X S 12 ga cut for 3" shells. Mostly I shot 2 3/4s for birds, but I decided to try some 3" shells for gobblers. To my shock, it shot far to the left point of aim, and about 18" low. Put in a field load and it was beautiful. Just something to think about.