Home
Posted By: RockyRaab Indonesian Sub Declared Lost - 04/24/21
After finding debris identified as coming from their missing submarine, the Indonesian Navy today declared the sub sunk with no chance of survivors. They will continue to search for whatever remains of the German-made submarine, which had been in service with the Indonesian Navy since 1981, to determine what happened to cause the loss, if possible. The sub, with a crew of 53, was on torpedo trials and about to submerge when it was last heard from on Thursday.
God bless the sailors!
Somehow I don't think this is hidden in a New England river like the Red October.
I remember when Thresher went down. It was shocking, and also mysterious and spooky. Something off the Twilight Zone.
Posted By: hanco Re: Indonesian Sub Declared Lost - 04/24/21
The Chinese probably sunk it or Trump did.


I don't see the issue, I am sure the krauts can build another.


Balibo five.
That's pretty crass, sir.
Originally Posted by RockyRaab
That's pretty crass, sir.




So was the indonesian killing of the bailbo five.


Fuck 'em.


And fuck any that have sympathy for them.
I wouldn't want to drive a 1979 car to Denver, let alone cruise around in a 1979 submarine.
thats a shame. hopefully they died quick. hats off to those that choose to serve in subs. i would never do it.

i lost track, is indonesia a friend or a foe anymore? hard to keep track these days. seems i read they were the largest muslim country or some such.

the women are little cuties for sure.



To the north-west of us and definitely not friendly.
Posted By: Boise Re: Indonesian Sub Declared Lost - 04/24/21
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balibo_Five
I hold a helluva lot more sympathy for the submariners than for five effing media types, to be honest. Even Indonesian submariners.
Originally Posted by RockyRaab
I hold a helluva lot more sympathy for the submariners than for five effing media types, to be honest. Even Indonesian submariners.



You must be thinking of your media types, those particular media types were actually real journalists recording a foreign invasion.
Quite possible, J. I'd never heard of them until your tag.

Edit to add: At any rate, and separate from one's viewpoint, a sub has been lost with all her crew. That's newsworthy and that's why I posted it.
Murdered by Kopassus, so I am given to understand.

Here

They executed another on the docks at Dili.


Posted By: NYNY Re: Indonesian Sub Declared Lost - 04/24/21
In Australia nd NZ it's only a question of who will invade first.

China or Indonesia.

AUS/NZ have joke militaries and NO Nukes.

As Israel and NOKO have proven, a small country with no nukes is an easy target.

Probably wait until world is diverted by Israel/Iran conflict to move in.

BTW Germany built Israel four nuke cruise missle capable subs, 2 of which are always on station with Iran in the crosshairs.
Originally Posted by NYNY
In Australia nd NZ it's only a question of who will invade first.

China or Indonesia.

AUS/NZ have joke militaries and NO Nukes.

As Israel and NOKO have proven, a small country with no nukes is an easy target.

Probably wait until world is diverted by Israel/Iran conflict to move in.

BTW Germany built Israel four nuke cruise missle capable subs, 2 of which are always on station with Iran in the crosshairs.



They will never invade, there is a rifleman behind every blade of grass.

Oh wait, they surrendered their guns to the govt. and all the grass burned up. Oh well I guess they're fugged. Ask their Abos about above ground nuclear testing.


mike r
Originally Posted by dogcatcher223
I wouldn't want to drive a 1979 car to Denver, let alone cruise around in a 1979 submarine.


Fugk that made me laugh.
"There will be a rifleman behind every blade of grass."

Good one.
Australia might very well be the only ally worth going and fighting for if it comes down to it.
53 dead Muslims, dead because of incompetence or internal Muslim sabotage.
Originally Posted by JSTUART



To the north-west of us and definitely not friendly.


A billion filthy muslims. Hell with em.
DISCLAIMER: No Christian missionaries were harmed during the sinking of this submarine.
I don't quite understand the purpose of having diesel boats unless it is to mess up the Straits of Malacca.
Posted By: NYNY Re: Indonesian Sub Declared Lost - 04/25/21
Dave, you need to catch up on Submarine technology.
I read the water is very deep where they lost that sub. Could be laying miles down on the bottom.
Originally Posted by NYNY
In Australia nd NZ it's only a question of who will invade first.

China or Indonesia.

AUS/NZ have joke militaries and NO Nukes.

As Israel and NOKO have proven, a small country with no nukes is an easy target.

Probably wait until world is diverted by Israel/Iran conflict to move in.

BTW Germany built Israel four nuke cruise missle capable subs, 2 of which are always on station with Iran in the crosshairs.

Never heard of the Commonwealth?
Originally Posted by OrangeOkie
I read the water is very deep where they lost that sub. Could be laying miles down on the bottom.

I wonder if it's deep enough to muffle the screams of terror from those subhuman crew members... Not for nutin' but just as a 'friendly' reminder there are lots of us here who recall your holier than thou bashing of & public 'ignoring' of STX and soon after seeing your classless post RE: hanging subhuman ethnic people. That despicable post of yours was deleted but for many of us your pathetic display of hypocrisy won't be overlooked. STX may be a lot of things, but I'll tell you here and now what he's not--starting with being a phony and someone who speaks out of two sides of his mouth. I'm grateful to you for your service to our nation but know this: if I were to ever witness you talking shyt to my brother Roger I'd crescent kick you right in your Okie grill.
Originally Posted by simonkenton7
I remember when Thresher went down. It was shocking, and also mysterious and spooky. Something off the Twilight Zone.

One of my 'student workers' at Northeastern Law in the late 90s was a former submariner. I recall him describing being at the helm in training and conducting an 'emergency blow'. I recall him laughing and describing how with the electric boat under his control he'd 'make that bitch sit up and bark' at his bequest. He also spoke of his late uncle who was lost at sea as crew aboard the Thresher...
Hmmm.....whats a crescent kick?

Sounds Muslim....
Originally Posted by Jim_Conrad
Hmmm.....whats a crescent kick?

Sounds Muslim....


I believe it’s Asian.
Originally Posted by Jim_Conrad
Hmmm.....whats a crescent kick?

Sounds Muslim....

Y'know Big Red, it seems like things have arrived at an impasse. You talking sheet and backed up by F lav'R Flav. I don't know [bleep] about cows but know enough to know when the billhillies start start displaying their base camp...
Originally Posted by Dave_Skinner
I don't quite understand the purpose of having diesel boats unless it is to mess up the Straits of Malacca.



Diesel subs are much quieter than nucs.
Originally Posted by sawbuck
Originally Posted by Dave_Skinner
I don't quite understand the purpose of having diesel boats unless it is to mess up the Straits of Malacca.



Diesel subs are much quieter than nucs.

Yep, the Oberons used to smoke every other sub in the was games
Originally Posted by sawbuck
Originally Posted by Dave_Skinner
I don't quite understand the purpose of having diesel boats unless it is to mess up the Straits of Malacca.



Diesel subs are much quieter than nucs.


BULLSHIT!



Full video is on YT below in case you want proof... laugh

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cyTcbSBIWTo
Posted By: NYNY Re: Indonesian Sub Declared Lost - 04/25/21
here's a cure for believing U Tube.

https://nationalinterest.org/blog/b...ealthy-non-nuclear-subs-ever-exist-80436
Posted By: g5m Re: Indonesian Sub Declared Lost - 04/25/21
Originally Posted by NYNY


Interesting article. Is the US doing anything with this propulsion system?
Mail

News

Reuters
Sunken missing Indonesian submarine found broken into pieces
Nilufar Rizki and Sultan Anshori
Sun, April 25, 2021, 1:54 AM·3 min read
By Nilufar Rizki and Sultan Anshori

DENPASAR (Reuters) -A missing Indonesian submarine has been found, broken into at least three parts, at the bottom of the Bali Sea, army and navy officials said on Sunday, as the president sent condolences to relatives of the 53 crew.

Rescuers also found new objects, including a life vest, that they believe belong to those aboard the 44-year old KRI Nanggala-402, which lost contact on Wednesday as it prepared to conduct a torpedo drill.

"Based on the evidence, it can be stated that the KRI Nanggala has sunk and all of its crew have died," military chief Marshal Hadi Tjahjanto told reporters.

Navy chief of staff Yudo Margono said the crew were not to blame for the accident and that the submarine did not experience a blackout, blaming "forces of nature".

"The KRI Nanggala is divided into three parts, the hull of the ship, the stern of the ship, and the main parts are all separated, with the main part found cracked," he said. "There are scattered parts of the submarine and its interior in the water."

President Joko Widodo earlier confirmed the discovery in the Bali Sea and sent the families of the victims his condolences.

"All of us Indonesians express our deep sorrow over this tragedy, especially to the families of the submarine crew."

A sonar scan on Saturday detected the submarine at 850 metres (2,790 feet), far beyond the Nanggala's diving range.

More than a dozen helicopters and ships are searching the area where contact was lost, with the United States, Australia, Singapore, and Malaysia providing assistance.

Navy officials said international help will be crucial in recovering the remains of the vessel.
Imploded, as expected. That Navy chief of staff is blowing smoke to save face of the crew. It had to be either a mechanical failure or crew error and either is as likely as the other.
Originally Posted by kamo_gari
Originally Posted by Jim_Conrad
Hmmm.....whats a crescent kick?

Sounds Muslim....

Y'know Big Red, it seems like things have arrived at an impasse. You talking sheet and backed up by F lav'R Flav. I don't know [bleep] about cows but know enough to know when the billhillies start start displaying their base camp...


I don’t know what any of that means?
Originally Posted by simonkenton7
... blaming "forces of nature"..


Is that a euphemism for poor maintenance, or taking an old boat below it's crush depth?
Originally Posted by RockyRaab
Imploded, as expected. That Navy chief of staff is blowing smoke to save face of the crew. It had to be either a mechanical failure or crew error and either is as likely as the other.


They claims it's in 3 pieces. Have to wonder if it cracked along the welds, or what?
Posted By: las Re: Indonesian Sub Declared Lost - 04/25/21
"torpedo test"
Sounds like an internal explosion.
Is Obama still an Indonesian citizen? Or did he give that up after using it to get through university?

I'd imagine the Germans build a decent sub. They've been doing it a long time and have built several.

Bb
What do they call it when they have a running torpedo in the tube and cant launch it???

"Hot fish" or something like that ???
An implosion is like an explosion, but in reverse. The hull fractures inward and upwards of 3,000 psi water pressure slams into every possible place, rupturing bulkheads, decks, and everything else in its path. It is not a slow leak; it's an extremely violent event. The usual result is multiple large pieces of structure and a large debris field of everything else.
Originally Posted by RockyRaab
An implosion is like an explosion, but in reverse. The hull fractures inward and upwards of 3,000 psi water pressure slams into every possible place, rupturing bulkheads, decks, and everything else in its path. It is not a slow leak; it's an extremely violent event. The usual result is multiple large pieces of structure and a large debris field of everything else.


Like squeezing an egg until it bursts all over the place.
Originally Posted by renegade50
What do they call it when they have a running torpedo in the tube and cant launch it???

"Hot fish" or something like that ???



Hot run
The sub had a test depth of 800 ft.
If its crush depth was 1500 ft the water pressure would have been about 665 psi.
Any bets against that they forgot to batten down the hatch?
Hmmm. The online depth/pressure calculator I used gave me an answer in atmospheres, so I multiplied by 14 to get psi. Somehow, my meager math skills let me down again. A different online calculator gives me roughly 875 psi at 600 meters or just under 2,000 feet LINK

Math errors aside, there are a whole damn lotta square inches on a sub, so 875 psi translates to a huge amount of pressure.
I find subs fascinating machines and sub warfare intriguing. A lot of my favorite movies have subs starring in them, but I sure as hell wouldn't want to work on one beyond the dock it's tied up to.
Originally Posted by RockyRaab
Hmmm. The online depth/pressure calculator I used gave me an answer in atmospheres, so I multiplied by 14 to get psi. Somehow, my meager math skills let me down again. A different online calculator gives me roughly 875 psi at 600 meters or just under 2,000 feet LINK

Math errors aside, there are a whole damn lotta square inches on a sub, so 875 psi translates to a huge amount of pressure.


Guys used to stash a styrofoam coffee cup in the conning tower before a deep dive. I was told they were much smaller when retrieved.
Originally Posted by stevelyn
I find subs fascinating machines and sub warfare intriguing. A lot of my favorite movies have subs starring in them, but I sure as hell wouldn't want to work on one beyond the dock it's tied up to.

[Linked Image from upload.wikimedia.org]

During World War II, the U.S. Navy's submarine service suffered the highest casualty percentage of all the American armed forces, losing one in five submariners. Some 16,000 submariners served during the war, of whom 375 officers and 3,131 enlisted men were killed.
oh man, i got a chuckle out of quite a few comments on this thread.

truth be told, bumping around indonesia, taking rickety trains, sketchy ferries and dangerous taxi rides with my family might be my best memories in life

indonesia is very diverse culturally. from sharia law in northern sumatra where separatists are fighting the jakarta government, to animist types in western guinea, to hedonistic balinese hindu's to christians occupying timor.

28million christians in the country.. but [bleep], they darkies. lol
Originally Posted by sawbuck
Originally Posted by stevelyn
I find subs fascinating machines and sub warfare intriguing. A lot of my favorite movies have subs starring in them, but I sure as hell wouldn't want to work on one beyond the dock it's tied up to.

[Linked Image from upload.wikimedia.org]

During World War II, the U.S. Navy's submarine service suffered the highest casualty percentage of all the American armed forces, losing one in five submariners. Some 16,000 submariners served during the war, of whom 375 officers and 3,131 enlisted men were killed.




The USS Grunion was just located off Kiska a couple years ago. The Grunion was lost on its first war patrol. As unfortunate as their loss was, I feel honored that they are resting in our waters. Even though that's still about 850mi W of me from the tip of the AKPEN.


Military.com Aug 2019






Originally Posted by Ndbowhunter
oh man, i got a chuckle out of quite a few comments on this thread.

truth be told, bumping around indonesia, taking rickety trains, sketchy ferries and dangerous taxi rides with my family might be my best memories in life

indonesia is very diverse culturally. from sharia law in northern sumatra where separatists are fighting the jakarta government, to animist types in western guinea, to hedonistic balinese hindu's to christians occupying timor.

28million christians in the country.. but [bleep], they darkies. lol



I like their coffee and cigar wrappers.
© 24hourcampfire