Home
Posted By: IZH27 Auto battery - 11/23/21
What are your thoughts on a good auto battery? Had one go toes up yesterday on a sedan.
Posted By: Redneck Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...
Posted By: rockinbbar Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Don't go to the dealer... laugh


https://www.24hourcampfire.com/ubbt...cs/13320478/truck-batteries#Post13320478
Posted By: wabigoon Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Walmart, sigh.
Posted By: hanco Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Interstate
Posted By: fburgtx Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
I like East Penn better than JCI batteries. Maybe that’s just me...
Posted By: skfullen Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
I just got a Duracell for my F250. $120 OTD for 850 CCA. The original battery went kaput after 3 years.
Posted By: Teal Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Whatever is on sale from Fleet Farm.


People over think some of this chit.
Posted By: badger Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Originally Posted by Redneck
FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...


Umm, no.

There are applications for AGM's in some vehicles where a conventional lead/acid battery won't cut it. If your vehicle calls for an AGM, use one.
Posted By: Ackleyfan Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Originally Posted by badger
Originally Posted by Redneck
FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...


Umm, no.

There are applications for AGM's in some vehicles where a conventional lead/acid battery won't cut it. If your vehicle calls for an AGM, use one.
[/quote
Originally Posted by badger
[quote=Redneck]FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...


Umm, no.

There are applications for AGM's in some vehicles where a conventional lead/acid battery won't cut it. If your vehicle calls for an AGM, use one.



What areas do AGM batteries excel ?
Posted By: Hotrod_Lincoln Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Price!
Posted By: badger Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Originally Posted by Ackleyfan
Originally Posted by badger
Originally Posted by Redneck
FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...


Umm, no.

There are applications for AGM's in some vehicles where a conventional lead/acid battery won't cut it. If your vehicle calls for an AGM, use one.
[/quote
Originally Posted by badger
[quote=Redneck]FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...


Umm, no.

There are applications for AGM's in some vehicles where a conventional lead/acid battery won't cut it. If your vehicle calls for an AGM, use one.



What areas do AGM batteries excel ?


Those vehicles that have a lot of electronics in are equipped with IBS's (Intelligent Battery Sensors). The AGM's have more reserve capacity as a rule, and if voltage drops below a certain threshold during high load situations (Cold starts, extended idling in hot weather with A/C on etc) the IBS's will often go into "Battery Saver" mode and selectively take non essential systems offline to preserve battery power to run the vehicle. Have seen lead acids in these applications fall on their faces many times.
Posted By: Ackleyfan Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Was in costco buying a battery the other day and noticed they are selling an Interstate agm, thanks Badger
Posted By: BamBam Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Originally Posted by fburgtx
I like East Penn better than JCI batteries. Maybe that’s just me...


I’ve had great luck with them.
Posted By: Bama_Rick Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
I sort of wish I never found this youtube channel, but he does some thorough testing on a lot of stuff. Good info here...

Project Farm - Battery
Posted By: slumlord Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Originally Posted by Ackleyfan
Originally Posted by badger
Originally Posted by Redneck
FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...


Umm, no.

There are applications for AGM's in some vehicles where a conventional lead/acid battery won't cut it. If your vehicle calls for an AGM, use one.
[/quote
Originally Posted by badger
[quote=Redneck]FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...


Umm, no.

There are applications for AGM's in some vehicles where a conventional lead/acid battery won't cut it. If your vehicle calls for an AGM, use one.



What areas do AGM batteries excel ?


They suck major donkey ball ass in Polaris atvs


Posted By: strikeu Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
go to Napa. always trust Napa. thank me later.
Posted By: Teal Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Originally Posted by strikeu
go to Napa. always trust Napa. thank me later.


My local NAPA didn't even carry anti-seize. Seriously.
Posted By: strikeu Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Originally Posted by Teal
Originally Posted by strikeu
go to Napa. always trust Napa. thank me later.


My local NAPA didn't even carry anti-seize. Seriously.


whatever. they'll have the battery you need at probably the best price and return policy, if the OP had asked where to get anti-seize I sure wouldn't have said go to Napa. smfh
Posted By: RickinTN Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
I have had good luck with Autozone and O'reilly batteries. Not sure who manufactures them.

Rick
Posted By: Teal Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
Originally Posted by strikeu
Originally Posted by Teal
Originally Posted by strikeu
go to Napa. always trust Napa. thank me later.


My local NAPA didn't even carry anti-seize. Seriously.


whatever. they'll have the battery you need at probably the best price and return policy, if the OP had asked where to get anti-seize I sure wouldn't have said go to Napa. smfh


An auto parts store that doesn't carry anti-seize is unlikely to have the proper battery in stock.
Posted By: reivertom Re: Auto battery - 11/23/21
I've had good luck with Auto zone Duralast batteries. No matter which one you choose, look at the date stickers on the side and get the newest one you can find. They can sit on the shelf for months and months before somebody buys them.
Posted By: Redneck Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by Hotrod_Lincoln
Price!
laugh laugh laugh


got THAT right...
Posted By: urbaneruralite Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Motorcraft hard to beat if its a Ford. Duracell otherwise.
Posted By: ironbender Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Timely.

I just replaced a pair of 10 1/2 year old motorcraft batteries (original) in my superduty.

Called NAPA, Carquest, O’reilly, and priced the Chinese embassy. Walmart had the best price (Johnson control).

Just for shîts and giggles, I called the local blue oval. They beat Walmart by 6 bucks each.

And, in spite of what Eddie at the Ford parts counter says, motorcraft doesn’t make the batteries.

They are JC same as WM. Both are the “Max” 3 year warranty battery.
Posted By: Ackleyfan Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by slumlord
Originally Posted by Ackleyfan
Originally Posted by badger
Originally Posted by Redneck
FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...


Umm, no.

There are applications for AGM's in some vehicles where a conventional lead/acid battery won't cut it. If your vehicle calls for an AGM, use one.
[/quote
Originally Posted by badger
[quote=Redneck]FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...


Umm, no.

There are applications for AGM's in some vehicles where a conventional lead/acid battery won't cut it. If your vehicle calls for an AGM, use one.



What areas do AGM batteries excel ?


They suck major donkey ball ass in Polaris atvs




Just replaced a Yuasa agm in my quad that was 8 Years old and still starting ….
Posted By: add Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by strikeu
go to Napa. always trust Napa. thank me later.


Maybe 20 yrs ago.
Posted By: add Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by Ackleyfan
Originally Posted by slumlord
Originally Posted by Ackleyfan
Originally Posted by badger
Originally Posted by Redneck
FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...


Umm, no.

There are applications for AGM's in some vehicles where a conventional lead/acid battery won't cut it. If your vehicle calls for an AGM, use one.
[/quote
Originally Posted by badger
[quote=Redneck]FWIW, ignore the AGM batteries... Just sayin'...


Umm, no.

There are applications for AGM's in some vehicles where a conventional lead/acid battery won't cut it. If your vehicle calls for an AGM, use one.



What areas do AGM batteries excel ?


They suck major donkey ball ass in Polaris atvs




Just replaced a Yuasa agm in my quad that was 8 Years old and still starting ….


Correct brand for the application.
Posted By: MattMan Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
If you’re asking here, ShuperShart at WalMart.

You’ll never know the difference.
Posted By: 5thShock Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Auto Zone Platinum AGM. Handles engine off, car off high current drain. Does a Subaru have electric dreams?
Posted By: K22 Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Interstate
Posted By: IZH27 Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Thanks for the suggestions.
Posted By: tikkanut Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21



Optima Red Top ???????

Just bought two this year

https://www.optimabatteries.com/products/redtop
Posted By: Tide_Change Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
There are only three or four auto battery manufacturers, and they all manufacture batteries per their client's specs.

They are engineered to last just about as long as the warranty that is offered for the particular unit.

So - if you want a battery that will last 1 year, buy one with a 1 year warranty. Want it to last 3 years...etc. etc.
Posted By: 260Remguy Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Check out "Project Farm" on youtube. The guy tests products and seems to do a better than average job of doing it in an unbias manner..

He tested car batteries in 12/19 and recommended the Wal-Mart Maxx Everstart. He found that Johnson Controls makes around one-half of the car batteries made in the U.S. that are sold under a variety of brand names. I currently have these batteries in all seven of my cars, two of which sit more than they are driven as they are vehicles that we leave at our vacation homes and only use for a few weeks each year.
Posted By: smarquez Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by urbaneruralite
Motorcraft hard to beat if its a Ford. Duracell otherwise.


The Motorcraft OE battery in my F250 lasted 7 years. No other battery lasted more than 4 years.
Posted By: tikkanut Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21


Recently replaced a walmart Ever Start Maxx...

6.0L Chevy...lasted 7.5 years

No warning after that.....dead

That's where the one Red Top went in
Posted By: PaPa260 Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
NAPA batteries are made by DEKA. They are good batteries. That is all I use.
Posted By: Jim_Conrad Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
They are all pretty good these days.
Posted By: Whttail_in_MT Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by Tide_Change
and they all manufacture batteries per their client's specs.

Given the cost to shut down/start up production, I question if that's the case or not.
Posted By: Oldman03 Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Check out this site. Guy test several brands of batteries.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h7rTcBanpMk
Posted By: Whttail_in_MT Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by 260Remguy
He found that Johnson Controls makes around one-half of the car batteries made in the U.S. that are sold under a variety of brand names.

Johnson Controls got out of the automobile battery business.
Posted By: Whttail_in_MT Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by Bama_Rick
I sort of wish I never found this youtube channel, but he does some thorough testing on a lot of stuff. Good info here...

Project Farm - Battery


Originally Posted by 260Remguy
Check out "Project Farm" on youtube.

Originally Posted by Oldman03
Check out this site. Guy test several brands of batteries.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h7rTcBanpMk

It appears this guy is well liked.
Posted By: slumlord Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Walmart batteries??

No way I’d step foot in wally mart

Whadda they know about cars??

Somebody told me that place had groceries now

Sheesh!!


[Linked Image from i.postimg.cc]
Posted By: Jim_Conrad Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
I get my Guac at walmarto.
Posted By: 22250rem Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Recently replaced a 7 year old battery in my Tacoma that didn't die yet but was testing poorly. Local independent garage owner that I've known for years got me an Interstate battery. Says he's been selling them for years and they have been great, and this guy is no B.S. artist.
Posted By: 260Remguy Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by Whttail_in_MT
Originally Posted by 260Remguy
He found that Johnson Controls makes around one-half of the car batteries made in the U.S. that are sold under a variety of brand names.

Johnson Controls got out of the automobile battery business.


Yes, the battery business was sold and was renamed Clarios.

Same batteries, same plants, different name.
Posted By: Traveler52 Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
The OEM , AGM battery in my F150 is going on 6.5 years. Still good to go
Posted By: hotsoup Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
I usually go to autozone, buy the factory equivalent, and have them install it. Easy, peasy.
Posted By: Tide_Change Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by Whttail_in_MT
Originally Posted by Tide_Change
and they all manufacture batteries per their client's specs.

Given the cost to shut down/start up production, I question if that's the case or not.


Does Walmart make their own batteries? How about Costco? Do they manufacture Kirkland batteries?

Doubt it. They give their specs to a battery manufacturer, and the manufacturer actually produces them, no?
Posted By: WYcoyote Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by Whttail_in_MT
Originally Posted by Bama_Rick
I sort of wish I never found this youtube channel, but he does some thorough testing on a lot of stuff. Good info here...

Project Farm - Battery


Originally Posted by 260Remguy
Check out "Project Farm" on youtube.

Originally Posted by Oldman03
Check out this site. Guy test several brands of batteries.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h7rTcBanpMk

It appears this guy is well liked.


I case you missed this....

Posted By: Gringo Loco Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by ironbender
I just replaced a pair of 10 1/2 year old motorcraft batteries (original) in my superduty.

Called NAPA, Carquest, O’reilly, and priced the Chinese embassy. Walmart had the best price (Johnson control).

Just for shîts and giggles, I called the local blue oval. They beat Walmart by 6 bucks each.

And, in spite of what Eddie at the Ford parts counter says, motorcraft doesn’t make the batteries. They are JC same as WM. Both are the “Max” 3 year warranty battery.

I have to say that is surprising. Ford isn't known for having the best price on parts.
Posted By: Whttail_in_MT Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by Tide_Change
Originally Posted by Whttail_in_MT
Originally Posted by Tide_Change
and they all manufacture batteries per their client's specs.

Given the cost to shut down/start up production, I question if that's the case or not.


Does Walmart make their own batteries? How about Costco? Do they manufacture Kirkland batteries?

Doubt it. They give their specs to a battery manufacturer, and the manufacturer actually produces them, no?

I would say the battery manufacturers are not making a thousand and one differently speced batteries for all of the different retailers they sell to. It's more plausible to me they produce what they produce and the product gets labeled appropriately for each retailer.
Posted By: Teal Re: Auto battery - 11/24/21
Originally Posted by Whttail_in_MT
Originally Posted by Tide_Change
Originally Posted by Whttail_in_MT
Originally Posted by Tide_Change
and they all manufacture batteries per their client's specs.

Given the cost to shut down/start up production, I question if that's the case or not.


Does Walmart make their own batteries? How about Costco? Do they manufacture Kirkland batteries?

Doubt it. They give their specs to a battery manufacturer, and the manufacturer actually produces them, no?

I would say the battery manufacturers are not making a thousand and one differently speced batteries for all of the different retailers they sell to. It's more plausible to me they produce what they produce and the product gets labeled appropriately for each retailer.


Depends on the product and retailer. I know of some mfg's that most definitely make product to a different spec for retailers and not just change the label.
© 24hourcampfire