I wanted something different than a .45-70, so I went with a .45-90 #1 Sporting Rifle
Believe it or not, the wood is "only extra fancy" not presentation
30" std octagon, shot gun buttplate AA Wood finish, sights as shown. Last time it was at the range, it put 3 in 2 inches at 200 yards. The chamber is very tight, so loading is a little fussy, but it is a superbly made rifle.
For the OP, a .45-70 is never a mistake. There are a couple for sale right this moment at Shiloh.
My next one will probably be something lighter. Maybe a Saddle rifle in .40-65 or .38-55
Or maybe a .50-90