Back when I first started to shave it was what ever dad was using at the time because that was what was there.
More often than not it was Aqua Velva or sometimes Old Spice.

In my misspent single running around mid-late teens and early twenties I tried Jade East, English Leather, British Sterling as well as others I no longer remember the name of.
I finally settled on one called Baron. Pretty potent stuff. A drop or two is the limit for me.
Anymore than that is too much. A bottle lasts me a long time.

I still keep some Baron and Old Spice after shave around although I rarely ever used any even back when I was still shaving regularly. Now that I quit shaving I forget that I even have it.