Concur with GF1. Lots of 37's in this area. Well built, great shooters, like 37's and Remington 17's aren't worth a lot.
Since NY legalized rifles for big game across the state, this has created a flush of "slug guns" on the market. Add in the decline of pheasants and grouse, field shotguns, in general, are relatively cheap.
The duck and goose guys now have to have magnum autos. The trap and skeet guys have never shown much interest in pumps.
In last week or so, I saw a wood stocked 870 Wingmaster magnum action, Remchoke barrel, very good condition, in a shop with a $319 price tag.