For my money the vapor barrier boots are the only way to go. If you have no chance of running into water the felt options may be more comfortable. I like to hunt ptarmigan in the winter. These birds esp. willow ptarmigan will be found around the willows that grow along streams. Regardless of how cold it gets you can always find water along the streams and rivers. I have dropped into water a few times while doing this. Once in the Talkeetna river I was knee deep and another time I was waist deep before I managed to grab a bush. Both times I poured out the water and was able to get back without too much discomfort. The wool between the rubber layers can get wet if the airvalves are not closed. Once wet the boots are worthless. I seal the valves with silicone. My boots fit well and I can walk a long ways in them before I need to change socks. I have both the black and white boots. pak
