Originally Posted by mtmuley
how about I tell him about cartridges I know about that folks have killed elk with for years.

Going with what you KNOW would be a great place to start.

Instead, it seems you'd already decided his choice is inadequate. You just wanted some guys on the internet to back up what you were thinking. The same internet that has him so impressed with the cartridge.

As I stated, offer to help him. You both might learn something including its capabilities (& limitations) for ethical performance on game.


'Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.' -Carl Sagan