JDK- I will be interested to see what others say on this but I don't think the pro was "yanking your chain". I am the opposite shooting lh with right eye dominant. I didn't seem to have as much problem with it when younger but as I've aged and left eye became weaker, this has become more pronounced. Have tried to go back to traditional archery the past couple of years and shooting without sights has made this more challenging. Can you work around this shooting rh? Yes you can but I would look further into switching. Just my 2 cents after missing one of the nicest bucks of my life due to right eye trying to take over! Good luck with whatever you decide. Bruce