Home Forums Hunting & Shooting Hunter's Campfire Hobbit #2

Any go see the new Hobbit movie this weekend?


One of my favorite books of all time, but didn't care much for the first movie. Just didn't see the need for all the extras in it, curious about the second?

I did! I thought it was very good! But, and I am going to be careful to not ruin any spoilers here, the ending kinda ticked me off

One of my all time favorite books, as well. I've read it four or five times over the years.

My complaint about the movie's first installment last year had to do with the acting/directing. The performance by the characters/actors brought over from The Lord Of The Rings seemed lackluster to me by comparison to their excellent work in TLOTR. That was disappointing, and likely due to inferior direction in The Hobbit.

Had you read the book?

The acting in the first Hobbit seemed cartoonish compared to what Peter Jackson created in the LOTR series.

The wife and boys went to #2 last night, they enjoyed it.....

I would say wooden rather than cartoonish.

Yeah, I agree about the acting/direction in general of the first movie. That coupled with the UN-necceasary add on's just didn't do much for me.

My girlfriend said she wasn't going to go with me if I was going to criticize it (she hasn't read the book). I've got to be out of town AGAIN this week for work, so figured I'd go see it by myself.


ps: I've probably read the book at least 4 times, maybe five times in my life as well.

If you didn't like the extras in the first, you won't care for the second movie. There are whole new characters and it really diverges from the book. There is more cartoonish action as well. The audience, including my wife, seemed to really enjoy the cartoonish action parts.

I thought Peter Jackson should have been shot for what he did to the Hobbit, first installment. Making three full length movies out of a small book was nothing but blatant commercialism in the first place.
From what I see of the second iteration, it will be even worse than the abomination the first one was. This adding new, and useless characters, such as the 'elf maiden', and the total travesty of turning the escape from the Elf King's underground fortress into something 180 out from what Tolkein wrote, is just awful.
The hutzpah of Jackson, thinking he knows Tolkein's thoughts better than JRR did himself!!!

..........then, on the other hand, it's the only Hobbit movie out there. Yeah, I'll go, but I won't be happy with it.

The book was cartoonish compared to LOTR. It was written more as a kids book while LORT was much more adult.

My thoughts exactly...

And if I'm still alive/breathing as much as I may hate the 2nd one, I'll go donate more money for the third installment.

This is true. I found the LOTR books boring at times (overly descriptive), while The Hobbit has never, at any point, bored me, though.

I said the acting, and costumes were cartoonish like, I'm comparing movie to movie.....

I saw it last night. It's a good action/fantasy flick. Better character development and plot, I thought, than the first one. As far as the book, it was probably 30 years ago that I read it. About all I remember is the name of the dragon.

If you like the genre, go for it.

IF you didn't call it the Hobbit, it was a pretty decent action flick. I'm convinced that Jackson read the cliff notes and decided to spice it up. Several made up sequences/relationships. The CGI guys had fun, though. In any case, it was somewhat entertaining, but to call it 'The Hobbit' is a travesty. He should have said 'Loosely based on The Hobbit' Just my two cents.

Went with my son on Friday. He really liked it but I thought it was too long for what you got (or didn't get)....I guess I'm still partial to the old animated one!!

i may go see it today. I have read the original books countless times.
and, it is kind of a joke in the family, i got this thing for elfen princesses. I think its the ears.

Saw it last night with my bride and daughter, they loved it. If you're going to compare it to the book, probably shouldn't go. For a no-deep-thinking-required, fantasy/action flick, it's worth seeing. Plus, our theater serves Boulevard Wheat draft.........

You mean elven princesses, right??

Never having read the books,or seen the other movies, I liked the movie, but anyone who didn't like the elven princess is a [bleep] queer.

She was HAWT, there was nothing about her I didn't like. I like redheads anyhow, and she was a VERY fine example of the breed. She was hotter than a $2 Colt Python.