1:8

No downside to the faster twist for a hunting rifle.

As for barrel maker:

You should narrow your choices first.

Do you want a chrome moly barrel (i.e. for bluing) or a stainless barrel? Not all makers make chrome moly barrels.

Do you want a specific contour? Several makers, i.e. Krieger, will not make a skinny or standard weight stainless barrel.

Do you have a preference for cut rifled vs button rifled?

Do you have a preference for a barrel maker from a particular part of the country?

Do you have a specific timeline, i.e. less than 6 months?

Do you have a gunsmith, or do you want the barrel maker to install the barrel?

Once you start answering these questions for yourself, you start whittling down barrel makers.