I have two 35 Remington's - a 141 Remington and a 336 Marlin. I have a 358 Win in a Remington 700 carbine. I like each and shoot cast bullets in each for the fun of it.
I only use RN bullets in the 35 Remington, they all seem to work well - more experience with the Remington CL's though and that's my first choice. Components for the 35 are not always easy to find... Stock up when you find them.
Hornady LR seems to me like "WHY??".
If I were hunting elk, my choice for cartridges (of the two) would be the 358 Win and I think that it would be a great cartridge for that especially in the thick woods.
The only reason I would pick the 358 over the 35 on deer would be shooting at 150+ yards and then I'd probably choose any cartridge such as 257 Roberts through an 06 then, but a 358 would be good too.
On the other hand 358 brass is easier to fashion than the 35 Remington brass, (components again)
