The tickets that come with under-age/size sheep kills are not free. Who paid those?
I see no problem with asking for ALL your money back for your friend. The guide has consequences atop yours and his was probably spendy.
Judging sheep for age as a test of legal status is ridiculous and it sounds like the guide does this routinely.
Do you have pictures of the sheep you can post?
It is technically against the law to purchase trophies at the auctions from critters you had confiscated from you. It is illegal for you to possess a trophy you took illegally.
Lots of those get used in various ways by ADF&G, like displays to help people understand how to judge a legal sheep, head mounts for schools, and such. I cleaned one up after splitting for the Anchorage office to show what the annuli look like inside the horn.
This is a link to the best piece they put out on judging sheep after the fact...
https://www.adfg.alaska.gov/static/...eep_horns_under_full_curl_regulation.pdf
